Home › Who We Help › Roofing and Remodeling › Crew Leads Who Stay

Where Do Roofing Companies Find Crew Leads Who Stay?
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, hears the same story from roofing owners: the best lead they ever had left to start his own company, and took two installers with him. It makes sense. A good lead already runs the roof, talks to the homeowner and knows your prices. If he is paid like an installer and laid off every winter, his own truck looks like a raise. Roofing companies that keep leads pay them like the roof depends on them, keep them working in the slow months and give them a reason to build your company instead of their own.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Find Roofing Crew Leads and Keep Them?
Look first at your best installer and the lead installers on sub crews you already trust; they know your roofs. Then keep them: pay leads per square on top of their base, and hold back part of it until the roof passes 90 days with no leak call. Keep leads working all winter on repairs, inspections and storm-prep work, so winter is not a layoff. Give a lead a real step up: running a second crew, training installers or a share of profit on his jobs.
How This Guide WorksThis guide covers the roofing labor market, a sample lead pay plan with a quality holdback, where to find leads, three steps and a story where a badger roofer’s best lead nearly starts a company of his own. More stories like the badger’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
The Labor Market
Why Are Good Roofing Crew Leads So Hard to Keep?
Because everyone wants them. Associated Builders and Contractors projects construction must attract about 349,000 workers in 2026, rising to 456,000 in 2027 as spending recovers and retirements speed up, as Roofing Contractor reported. Sage Economics points to roofing at the center of construction wage pressure and tighter labor, per RoofersCoffeeShop, even where average roofer labor costs have risen slowly. A lead who can run a roof has offers, including the one he can make himself with a truck.
A Sample
What Does a Lead Pay Plan With a Holdback Look Like?
| Piece | Sample |
|---|---|
| Base pay | Hourly or day rate, above top installer pay |
| Square bonus | $10 per square the crew installs |
| Holdback | 20% of the bonus, paid after 90 days with no leak call |
| One 30-square roof | $300 bonus: $240 now, $60 at 90 days |
| 1,500 squares a season | $15,000 in bonus |
| Winter | Repairs, inspections and training new installers at full base pay |
What to Do
How Do I Build a Crew Lead Plan That Keeps Leads?
Keeping roofing leads takes three stages, set out in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
List what your leads earn per year, how many weeks they work and why the last one left. Count your leak callbacks by lead.
Write the lead pay plan: base pay, a per-square bonus and a 90-day quality holdback. Build a winter work plan for leads: repairs, inspections and training the next season’s installers.
Offer the plan to your best installer and your most trusted sub crew lead. Review each lead’s squares, callbacks and homeowner reviews every quarter.
Planning your second crew? Put a lead pay plan and winter work into your budget before you add the crew. The roofing contractor business plan template has a staffing plan to build from.
Installer who wants to lead? Ask the owner to let you run the next small roof from the checklist. A clean roof with no callback is your case.
Dr. Paul’s Take
Pay the Lead Like the Roof Depends on Him
Owners pay leads a little more than installers and hope loyalty does the rest. Dr. Paul has them pay for what a lead controls: speed, quality and the homeowner’s experience. A per-square bonus with a 90-day holdback pays for all three, and a lead who earns it rarely needs his own truck. Add work in the slow months, and the reason to leave shrinks. Building that pay plan and lead path with you is the work in Dr. Paul’s strategic planning consulting.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did the Badger’s Best Lead Almost Leave?
On the riverbank, the old ferryman was teaching a young heron to read the current. Doctor Owl was watching when the badger roofer found him.
“My best lead is buying a truck,” the badger said. “His own. He says he can roof the same houses and keep all of it.”
“How much does he make now?”
“Same as the installers, near enough.”
“And in winter?”
The badger looked at the river. “I lay everyone off in winter.”
“So he works for you nine months, and in the tenth he thinks about a truck.”
That night the badger did the sums. His lead ran most of his best roofs, almost never had a leak call and the families asked for him by name. He was paid like any installer.
He made his lead an offer. A bonus for every square his crew roofed, with a part of it held back until each roof passed ninety days with no leak. Repairs, inspections and training new installers all winter, at full pay. And when the second crew started, the lead would train its lead.
The lead did the sums too. A truck, insurance, a dump trailer and his own phone calls at night. He stayed.
The next summer his crew roofed more squares than ever, and the holdback came back to him almost every time.
The ferryman’s heron took the boat across alone that fall. The old ferryman had taught him every eddy first.
The lesson: a good lead stays when the pay rewards what he controls and the work does not stop in winter.
The badger and his lead live in the Fabled Forest. The lead who leaves to buy his own truck lives everywhere.
Myth and Reality
What Do Roofers Get Wrong About Crew Leads?
Myth: the fastest installer makes the best lead. Reality: the best lead is the one the crew already follows.
Myth: good leads have to come from outside. Reality: start with your own installers and the sub crew leads you already trust.
Myth: winter layoffs are just roofing. Reality: a layoff every winter is when a lead prices his own truck.
Myth: a bigger hourly rate keeps them. Reality: a per-square bonus with a quality holdback pays for what a lead controls.
What Else Do Roofers Ask About Crew Leads?
How much of the bonus should I hold back?
Enough to matter, such as a fifth of it, paid when the roof passes 90 days with no leak call. Keep the rule simple and pay it on time.
What if my lead wants to start his own company anyway?
Some will. A fair pay plan, steady work and a path up keep most. For the rest, part on good terms; some become your best subcontractors.
Should leads be employees or subcontractors?
If you set their schedule, methods and tools, they are usually employees. Misclassifying them creates tax and insurance trouble. Ask your accountant.
I’m starting a roofing company. Do I need a lead pay plan yet?
Write it before your first lead, even if it is you. A plan written early is easier to keep fair than one made up when a lead threatens to leave.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He builds the lead pay plan and holdback with you and sets up the quarterly review of squares, callbacks and reviews.
This guide is one of six for roofing and remodeling owners. The others are on the Roofing and Remodeling page.
A Virginia foreman grew into his first manager role: see the Richmond business consultant page.
A strong lead is what makes a second crew possible. Then comes running two roofing crews without losing control.
Is Your Best Lead Shopping for a Truck?
A lead paid like an installer will eventually do the math. Dr. Paul builds lead pay plans and year-round work with roofers in strategic planning consulting. Bring your lead roster and last season’s squares to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.
Talk About Your Leads on a Free Call
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- Roofing Contractor, Construction industry must attract 349,000 workers in 2026 (Associated Builders and Contractors), January 2026.
- RoofersCoffeeShop, Roofing leads the way as wages create pressure for construction (Sage Economics).
