Home › Who We Help › Dental and Medical Offices › Partner Disagreements

How Do Dental Practice Partners Resolve Disagreements?
You bought in together because you trusted each other. Five years later, one of you wants a third operatory and an associate, and the other wants to pay down the practice loan first. Neither is wrong. The decision sits for months, the staff notice the tension and both of you start making small choices alone. Many partner disputes are not about the question at all. They are about having no agreed way to decide. Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has advised more than 1,000 small businesses and helps partners set that up.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do Dental Practice Partners Resolve Disagreements?
Agree on how you decide before you argue about what to decide. List the decisions that come up, then mark which ones each partner makes alone, which need both and what happens in a tie, such as a named outside advisor or a mediator. Put it in your shareholder or operating agreement with your attorney, along with a buy-sell section for when one partner wants out. Meet monthly on practice business, away from the patient schedule.
How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with a story where the otter who runs the forest’s busiest clinic and her partner stop arguing at the door, then a decision table, three steps, Dr. Paul’s view, what a partnership agreement should cover and three myths. More stories like the otter’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did the Otter and Her Partner Stop Arguing at the Door?
Doctor Owl was writing the rules for the autumn chess tournament: who moves first, how long each turn lasts and who settles a dispute. The rules took an hour. They would save a week of quarrels.
The otter came up the library steps with the badger who shared her clinic. They had been arguing since the riverbank.
“She wants to build a second room,” the badger said. “I want to pay the beavers back for the first one.”
“He has said no to everything this year,” the otter said.
“Who decides when you disagree?” Doctor Owl asked.
They looked at each other. Nobody had ever said.
Doctor Owl handed them a blank page. That afternoon they wrote down every choice they had faced together. Some were clearly hers: how she ran her patients. Some were clearly his: the stores and the accounts. The big ones, rooms and debts and new helpers, needed both. And if they still disagreed after a full moon, they would ask the old tortoise, who owed neither of them anything.
They met on the first evening of every moon, away from the clinic. The second room came up first. They agreed to pay down half the beavers’ debt, then build.
In the library, the tournament ran without a single quarrel. Everyone knew the rules.
The lesson: partners can disagree on anything, as long as they agreed first on how to decide.
The otter, the badger and the old tortoise are from the Fabled Forest. Partners stuck on the same question for months are real.
Who Decides
Which Practice Decisions Need Both Partners?
More dentists now share an office. The share in solo practice fell from 36.5% in 2022 to 32.6% in 2025, and 39.2% worked in a single location with at least one other dentist, per ADA Health Policy Institute data reported by Becker’s Dental Review. Every shared office needs rules for sharing decisions.
| Decision | Who decides | If you disagree |
|---|---|---|
| Your own patient care | Each partner | No vote needed |
| Office hours and days open | Both | Tie-breaker after 30 days |
| Supplies and repairs under a set limit | Assigned partner or office manager | Raise it at the monthly meeting |
| Hiring staff and setting pay ranges | Both | Tie-breaker after 30 days |
| New associate, operatory or location | Both | Tie-breaker after 30 days |
| New debt or a large purchase | Both | No change without agreement |
Your list will differ. Write it together.
What to Do
How Do Partners Set Up a Way to Decide?
Setting up the process takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Each partner lists, alone, the decisions of the last two years and the ones coming up. Compare lists and note where you disagreed.
Sort every decision into one partner, both partners or tie-breaker. Name the tie-breaker. Set a monthly partner meeting with a written agenda.
Take the list to your attorney for your shareholder or operating agreement. Use the monthly meeting for the open decision first, and write down what you agree.
Buying in with a partner? Write the decision list before you sign. The dentist office business plan template has an ownership and management section to work from.
Dr. Paul’s Take
Disagreeing Is Normal. Having No Way to Decide Is the Problem.
Partners often think a dispute means the partnership is failing. Dr. Paul sees it differently: two owners will disagree, and the practice suffers only when nobody knows how a tie gets broken. A written decision list and a monthly partner meeting turn a standoff into an agenda item. Running that first meeting and writing the list is the work in Dr. Paul’s conflict resolution consulting.
In Writing
What Should a Dental Partnership Agreement Cover?
Most co-owned practices are a professional corporation or PLLC, so these terms live in the shareholder or operating agreement.
- Which decisions each partner makes and which need both.
- The tie-breaker and how long you try before using one.
- How each partner is paid, and how expenses are shared.
- Buy-sell terms: how a share is valued and paid when a partner retires, leaves, becomes disabled or dies.
- Non-compete and patient record terms, as your state allows.
Have a healthcare attorney draft or review it. Dr. Paul works on the business side, not the legal side.
Myth and Reality
What Do Partners Get Wrong About Disagreements?
Myth: Good partners always agree. Reality: good partners agree on how to decide.
Myth: The senior partner should break ties. Reality: ownership shares matter, so set tie rules with your attorney. If you name an outside tie-breaker, confirm your state allows that person to decide practice matters.
Myth: We will write it down if things get bad. Reality: by then neither of you will agree on the wording.
What Else Do Dental Partners Ask About Disagreements?
Who should be our tie-breaker?
Someone both partners trust and who has no stake in the outcome: an outside advisor, a mediator or a consultant. Name the person in writing before you need one, and confirm with your attorney what that person may decide under your state’s rules.
What if one partner produces more?
Production and decision rights are separate questions. Settle pay in the compensation formula, and decision rights in the agreement.
Should we tell the staff we disagree?
Tell them who decides what. Settle disagreements in your partner meeting, not in the hallway.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He runs the first partner meeting, helps you build the decision list and works with your attorney on the business side of the agreement.
This is one of six guides for dental and medical practice owners. See them all on the Dental and Medical Offices page.
Putting off a hard choice is common in every business. See the Sarasota business consultant page.
Behind schedule often means short-staffed; here is an offer that wins hygienists and assistants.
Which Decision Has Been Waiting the Longest?
Start there. Book a free 15-minute call, and Dr. Paul will help you set up the process before you tackle the question. He works with practice partners in conflict resolution consulting, with rates on the pricing page.
Plan Your First Partner Meeting
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- Becker’s Dental Review, Is practice ownership still the endgame for dentists? 10 stats to know (November 2026), on the ADA Health Policy Institute report The U.S. Dentist Workforce.
