Home › Who We Help › Moving and Delivery › Damage Claims

How Do Moving Companies Reduce Damage Claims?
The move went fine. Then, two days later, the email: a gouge in the dining table, a scuff down the hallway wall and a lamp that will not turn on. Was the gouge already there? Nobody can say, because nobody looked. You pay the claim to keep the review clean, and next month it happens again with a different crew. Claims are not bad luck. They come from a few steps that get skipped on busy days. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, a business consultant to more than 1,000 small businesses, helps moving owners find which ones.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do Moving Companies Reduce Damage Claims?
Write down the condition of every large item and the walls before anything moves, and track every claim by crew. Walk the home with the customer at the start, photograph existing scratches and get a signature. Set a wrap card for what gets pads, shrink wrap and floor or door protection. Walk through again before the truck leaves. Then log each claim by crew and by where it happened: wrap, carry, load or unload.
How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with claims by crew, then three steps, a story where Otto the Octopus of Eight-Arm Errands learns to look before he lifts, a condition report checklist, Dr. Paul’s view and how to talk about coverage. More stories like Otto’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
Claims by Crew
How Do I Find Where Damage Claims Start?
| Summer, sample | Moves | Claims | Cost | Per 100 moves |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crew A | 40 | 1 | $180 | 2.5 |
| Crew B | 38 | 5 | $2,950 | 13.2 |
| Crew C | 42 | 2 | $640 | 4.8 |
Example only. Sort each claim by where it happened, too. A crew with most of its claims at the load step has a loading habit to change, not a wrapping one.
What to Do
How Do I Cut Damage Claims?
Cutting claims follows three stages: Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Pull every claim from the last 12 months. Note the crew, the item, the cost and where it happened: wrap, carry, load or unload.
Write the condition report and the wrap card. Train every crew lead on both, with photos of what good looks like.
Use both on every job. Review claims per 100 moves by crew each month, and ride along with the crew that runs highest.
Starting a moving company? Build the condition report into your first estimate form. The moving company business plan template has an operations section for it.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Otto Start Looking Before He Lifted?
Doctor Owl was wrapping the library’s oldest atlas in soft moss before lending it to the next village. He checked every corner first and wrote down the torn page on the back cover.
Otto the Octopus came by, all eight arms full of errands. “The rabbits say I scratched their great chest,” he said. “I did not. I think. I carried it so fast, I cannot be sure.”
Tobias the old turtle was in the library too, doing Otto’s books. “That is the fourth chest this season,” he said. “It cost us more than the moves paid.”
“Did you look at the chest before you lifted it?” Doctor Owl asked.
“I never look. I lift.”
So Otto changed one thing first. At every burrow, before a single arm lifted anything, he walked around with the family. He pointed out every old scratch and they marked it on a leaf together.
Then he made a rule card: chests and tables get moss, mirrors get bark boards and the doorways get leaves on the floor. He checked again with the family before he left.
Tobias kept a list of every complaint by which helper carried the item. Most came from the young crab, who carried everything with one claw. Otto taught him to use two.
By the end of the season, Tobias had very little to write in the complaint column.
At the library, the atlas came back from the next village. The torn page was the only mark on it.
The lesson: look and write before you lift, and you will know which damage is yours.
Otto, Tobias and the young crab are from the Fabled Forest. The gouge nobody can explain two days later is real.
Checklist
What Goes on a Condition Report?
- Every large item: existing scratches, dents and loose parts, with photos.
- Walls, floors and doorways along the carry path, both homes.
- Items the customer packed themselves, marked as such.
- High-value items the customer declared in writing.
- Customer signature at the start and at the final walk-through.
Dr. Paul’s Take
You Cannot Defend a Claim You Did Not Document
Owners pay small claims to protect reviews, then wonder why claims keep coming. Dr. Paul points out two problems. Without a signed condition report, there is no way to tell new damage from old. And without a claims log by crew, there is no way to know which habits cause it. Building the report, the wrap card and the log is the work in Dr. Paul’s business process improvement consulting.
Coverage
How Should I Explain Coverage to Customers?
Customers often think every item is covered at full value. For interstate moves, federal rules require movers to offer full value protection and a released value option that pays no more than 60 cents per pound per article, so a 25-pound TV pays about $15, per the FMCSA. Full value protection is the default; the customer gets released value only by choosing it in writing. For interstate claims, acknowledge each written claim within 30 days and settle it within 120 days. Local moves follow your state’s rules.
What Else Do Moving Owners Ask About Damage Claims?
Should I pay small claims to avoid a bad review?
Sometimes it is the right call. Log every one, even small ones, so you can see the pattern, and handle interstate claims under the federal claim rules.
How long should a condition report take?
About ten minutes on a typical home. Photos of the big pieces and the walls along the path matter most.
Do I need different coverage rules for local moves?
Interstate moves follow federal valuation rules. Local moves follow your state’s rules and your tariff. Check both.
Should crews pay for damage?
Be careful. Many states limit pay deductions, and no deduction can drop pay below minimum wage. Reward low claims instead.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He builds the condition report, wrap card and claims log with you and reviews the crew numbers each month.
This is one of six guides for moving and delivery owners. See them all on the Moving and Delivery page.
Crews skipping steps on busy days is a common problem. See the Waterbury business consultant page.
Fewer claims make a fair quote go further. Here is quoting local moves from an inventory.
Which Crew Had the Most Claims This Year?
Bring your claims list to a free 15-minute call, and Dr. Paul will help you find the pattern. He builds claims systems for moving owners in business process improvement consulting. His rates are on the pricing page.
Review Your Claims With Dr. Paul
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, Valuation and insurance.
