Home › Who We Help › Towing Companies › Losing Calls to Competitors

How Do I Stop Losing Tow Calls to Competitors?
Two trucks sat in the yard Tuesday afternoon. Meanwhile, three motor club offers popped up on the dispatch tablet and timed out before anyone saw them. The one you did accept, you quoted 30 minutes and arrived in 55. This month the club is sending you fewer offers, and you are not sure why. The answer is in their numbers: how fast you accept, how often you take what they send and whether you arrive when you said you would. The clubs measure all three. Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has advised more than 1,000 small businesses and helps towing owners measure them first.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Stop Losing Tow Calls to Competitors?
Accept fast, quote ETAs you can keep and keep every truck visible on GPS. Put one person in charge of the dispatch screen at all times, with a target to accept in under a minute. Quote ETAs from where your trucks really are. Turn on driver location sharing. Then track acceptance rate, ETA accuracy and missed offers every week, the same numbers the clubs use to pick who gets the next call.
How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with how motor clubs choose providers, then a story where the steady ox who runs the forest’s tow wagons learns why the rabbits stopped calling, Dr. Paul’s view, three steps, a weekly scorecard and dispatch rules. More stories like the ox’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
How Clubs Choose
How Do Motor Clubs Decide Which Towing Company Gets a Call?
The clubs score you. Agero, for example, has made acceptance rate and driver location sharing part of how it selects providers, and has said it is adding ETA accuracy to reward providers who meet their quoted times, per its provider FAQ.
Other clubs and dispatch networks use similar numbers. Ask each one which measures it uses for your territory.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did the Rabbits Stop Calling the Ox?
Doctor Owl was timing how long it took the library helpers to answer a knock at the door. Some answered at once. Some let it knock three times.
The steady ox came in with a long face. “The rabbits used to call me for every stuck cart,” he said. “Now they call the boar.”
“Is the boar stronger?”
“No. Slower, too.”
“How long do the rabbits wait for you to answer?”
The ox thought. “Sometimes I am out in the field. Sometimes nobody hears them.”
“And when you say you will be there by midday?”
“I am there by afternoon. Usually.”
The ox asked the rabbits. They said the boar answered at once, said a time and arrived by it.
So the ox set a young sparrow by the call post, all day, to answer at once. The sparrow could see where every ox and wagon was from the hilltop, so she said times that were true. Every new moon, the ox counted how fast they answered and how often they arrived on time.
By the next season, the rabbits were calling the ox again.
In the library, every helper answered the door on the first knock.
The lesson: answer fast, promise a time you can keep and keep it.
The ox, the rabbits, the boar and the sparrow are from the Fabled Forest. The offers that time out while trucks sit in the yard are real.
Dr. Paul’s Take
The Next Call Goes to Whoever Answered the Last One Well
Owners blame lost calls on cheaper competitors. Dr. Paul looks at the dispatch screen instead. Offers that time out, ETAs that slip and trucks that do not show on GPS all push your company down the list. Change those, and more offers tend to follow with no new marketing spend. Setting up the dispatch rules and the weekly scorecard is the work in Dr. Paul’s business process improvement consulting.
What to Do
How Do I Win More Motor Club Calls?
Winning more calls takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Pull last month’s offers from each club: accepted, timed out, declined, ETA quoted and arrival time.
Name a dispatch owner for every hour. Set an accept target, ETA rules and turn on GPS sharing for every driver.
Review the scorecard every Monday. Talk to the club rep monthly about your numbers and territory.
Signing your first club? Plan dispatch coverage before the offers start. The towing company business plan template has an operations section to plan from.
Weekly Scorecard
What Should a Towing Dispatch Scorecard Track?
| One club, one week, sample | Number |
|---|---|
| Offers received | 64 |
| Accepted | 44 |
| Timed out without an answer | 12 |
| Declined | 8 |
| Acceptance rate | 69% |
| Arrived within the quoted ETA | 35 of 44, 80% |
Example only. The 12 timeouts are the first target: most were calls nobody saw in time.
Dispatch Rules
What Dispatch Rules Help a Towing Company Win More Calls?
- One named person watches the dispatch screen every hour you are open.
- Accept or decline in under a minute.
- Quote ETAs from the nearest truck’s GPS location, plus a buffer for traffic.
- Update the ETA in the app the moment a driver is running late.
- Every driver shares location the whole shift.
What Else Do Towing Owners Ask About Dispatch?
Should I accept every offer to raise my acceptance rate?
No. Accept what you can complete on time. A missed ETA or a cancellation hurts more than a decline.
Do I need new dispatch software?
Start with the club’s own app and GPS sharing. Add software when you run several clubs and fleet accounts at once.
What about police rotation calls?
Response time rules are set by each agency. Track them the same way and keep a truck staged when your rotation is up.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He sets up the dispatch rules, the scorecard and the weekly review with you.
This is one of six guides for towing company owners. See them all on the Towing Companies page.
Calls coming in but not turning into jobs? See the Palm Bay business consultant page.
Winning more calls only helps if they get paid; read an aging report and short-pay log for towing.
How Many Offers Timed Out on You Last Month?
Bring last month’s offer report to a free 15-minute call. Dr. Paul sets up towing dispatch in business process improvement consulting. Rates are on the pricing page.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
