Home › Current Small Business Issues › Hiring

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Why Can’t My Small Business Find Qualified Workers?

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a business consultant for owners who are experts at their craft and were never shown how to hire for it. If your ad has been up for six weeks and you are covering the open spot yourself, this guide is for you. It shows why the same hiring problem looks different in a restaurant, an HVAC shop and a home care agency, what each should measure and how his operations service helps.

Stage 1 of 3: Organize

Most small businesses struggle to hire because the job was never clearly defined. Start in the Organize stage of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, which has three stages in all. Here, Organize means writing down what the role does, what skills it truly needs and how you will train for the rest. A business consultant helps you build that scorecard and a hiring process you can repeat.

Text or call (321) 948-9588 for a free 15-minute first call.

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Why Is It So Hard to Find Good Workers?

There are fewer skilled people looking, and every shop wants the same ones. You cannot change that. You can change how clear your job is. Say what the person will do, what you will teach and what a good first month looks like. Clear jobs get better applicants.

New here? Doctor Owl is a character from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest books. His short answers on this site are real business advice.

The Full Answer

What Are the Real Reasons Good Workers Are Hard to Find?

There are usually five, and you control four of them.

  1. The job is not clear. A vague ad attracts vague applicants. List the five tasks, the hours and what you will teach.
  2. The pay is off the local mark. Check what three nearby competitors offer for the same work. If you are well below, no ad will save you.
  3. You answer too slowly. Good applicants take the first solid offer. Reply within one business day and interview within the week.
  4. You are looking in one place. Ask your current team for referrals, call the local trade school and go back to past applicants.
  5. The skilled pool is small. This is the one you cannot change. Hire for attitude and the core tasks, then train the rest on a 30-day plan.

What This Means for Your Business

Why Does the Hiring Problem Look Different in Every Trade?

An open job does not sit quietly. Work gets delayed, your best people pick up the slack and you end up doing the job yourself. A rushed hire then makes it worse. But the reason good people are hard to find, and hard to keep, changes from one trade to the next.

In a restaurant

Finding people is the easy half. Keeping them past the first 90 days is the hard half. A new cook thrown onto a Friday rush with a schedule that changes every week does not stay. The guide on hiring and keeping restaurant employees starts with the schedule, not the ad.

In HVAC and plumbing

Skilled techs are scarce, and summer burns out the ones you have. Long weeks and on-call nights with no plan push good techs to leave in the fall. See finding and keeping HVAC technicians.

In home care

Applicants are out there, and they apply to several agencies at once. The agency that answers first usually gets the caregiver. Days lost between the application, the interview and the background check are days a competitor uses. The guide on recruiting caregivers faster covers each step.

So the question is not only where to find workers. A restaurant has to keep them. An HVAC shop has to protect them from the busy season. A home care agency has to move faster than the agency down the road.

What to Measure

What Hiring Benchmark Fits My Business?

Two numbers work everywhere. Time to fill is the days from posting a job to the first day of work. Time to independence is how long before the new hire can work without you. The second one matters more. Beyond those, watch the number that matches your trade’s weak spot.

TradeBenchmark to watchHow to read it
RestaurantsWho is still on the schedule at day 90Turnover is the trade norm: the monthly quits rate in accommodation and food services was 3.5%, against 1.9% for all jobs, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Beat your own last quarter.
HVAC and plumbingHours and on-call nights per tech, each weekWatch who leaves in the fall. Demand for techs is not easing: the Bureau of Labor Statistics projects about 40,600 openings a year.
Home careDays between each hiring stepCount the days from application to interview to first shift. Interviews held within 24 to 48 hours led to better results in a study reported by Home Health Care News.

Each benchmark points at a different repair. A restaurant with people leaving before day 90 has a training and schedule problem. An HVAC shop losing techs every fall has a workload problem. A home care agency with long gaps between steps has a speed problem.

No trade here? Track time to fill and time to independence for your next three hires and work on the larger of the two.

How a Business Consultant Can Help

How Does Business Operations Consulting Help You Hire and Keep People?

Hiring breaks down where the work is unclear, so the service that fits is Dr. Paul’s business operations consulting. It looks at how work moves through your business, from first contact to finished job, and builds routines that keep it moving.

First, Dr. Paul maps how the work really gets done: where it stalls, who touches each step and what the delays cost. Next, he designs how it should run, together with the people who do it. That means clear roles and handoffs, daily and weekly routines and a list of decisions staff can make without you. Then the routines go into practice and get measured.

Here is how that looks in each trade.

  • Restaurants: roles are set station by station, with a sign-off before a new hire adds the next one. The weekly routine includes posting the schedule two weeks ahead.
  • HVAC and plumbing: the routine is a posted on-call rotation and a cap on weekly hours, set before summer starts. Handoffs to a helper are written down.
  • Home care: the hiring steps become a routine with a day count on each one: same-day call, interview within two days, checks started on offer day.

Dr. Paul works with your team on site or over Zoom.

A practical deliverable

Defined roles and handoffs, daily and weekly routines and a short list of decisions your staff can make without you.

Current signal: the rank for hiring this month is on the top 10 small business problems countdown.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Hire for the Five Tasks, Train for the Rest

Many owners hold out for a perfect candidate who can do twenty things on day one. That person is rare and expensive. Pick the five tasks that matter most. Hire the person who can do those, and build a simple plan to teach the others.

Start Here

What Is My First Move?

Write down the five tasks your next hire must do well. Mark which ones you can teach and which ones they must bring.

Opening soon? Decide which jobs you will do yourself and which you will hire for. A business plan template has a labor section for exactly that.

On the management team? Draft the five-task list for the open role and bring it to the owner. It speeds up every step after.

What Should I Read Next?

Related issue: affording raises without losing profit. See all ten issues on the current small business issues countdown.

Sources

Trade details come from Dr. Paul’s industry guides, linked above. Featured trades change monthly.

You are leaving the real world. Welcome to the Fabled Forest.

How Does a Fabled Forest Honey Maker Fill an Empty Station?

A Fabled Forest Story: Beatrix and the Blank Card

Doctor Owl was reading the help-wanted cards pinned up at the general store. One card said only: HELP WANTED. BEATRIX FOREST HONEY.

Beatrix the Bee buzzed in behind him, crown crooked, honey on her hands.

“Two weeks that card has been up,” she said. “One beetle came. He left by lunch.”

“What did you ask him to do?” asked Doctor Owl.

“Whatever needed doing. I know it all by heart.”

“Does he?”

Beatrix stopped moving, which was rare. She turned to Juniper the Junebug, who was counting jars for the second time.

“Juniper, what are the five things you do at your station every day?”

Juniper listed them without looking up. Then she asked, “Is that allowed? Writing it down?”

“It is now,” said Beatrix. She wrote the five tasks on a fresh card and pinned it up. Four applicants came that week. Each one knew what the job was before they knocked.

“Well… that’s the bee’s buzz,” said Beatrix.

The lesson: a clear job finds a worker faster than a blank card.

More stories like Beatrix’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Illustration only. Beatrix and Juniper are made-up characters. Vague job ads are a real problem.

What Do Owners Also Want to Know About Hiring?

Should I raise the pay to get more applicants?

Check your pay against local rates first. If you are close, a clearer job and a faster reply to applicants often help more than a raise.

Where do small businesses find good workers?

Referrals from current staff, trade schools and past applicants are the three best places to start. Each one costs less than a job board.

I have not opened yet. When should I make my first hire?

When the work you must do yourself starts pushing out the work only you can do. Plan that point before opening day.

Expert at the Craft. Who Taught You to Hire?

Nobody trained you to write a job ad or run an interview. You learned your trade and then the business handed you a hiring problem. Dr. Paul helps owners set up a simple hiring process they can run again and again. Begin with the five tasks. For a hand with the rest, see his business consulting services or check the pricing page.

Schedule Your Free 15 Minutes

You can also text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, consults for small businesses and writes books, including Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. He earned an MBA in Finance at Webster University and a DBA at National University. Owners of over 1,000 small businesses, from every state and Canada, have hired him. On hiring, he starts with the role, not the ad. Meet Dr. Paul or find his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top