Home › Industry Trends › HVAC and Plumbing Trends › Training Your Own Techs or Hiring Them

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Should Trade Companies Train Their Own Techs or Hire Experienced Ones in 2027?

Your job ad has run for six weeks. Two people called. One wanted more than your lead tech makes. Meanwhile, a 19-year-old keeps asking if you need a helper. Which path builds a team faster? Trade owners put that question to Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA. His business consulting answer starts with the work that’s waiting.

Stage 2 of 3: Plan

Most shops need both: one experienced hire to carry the work, and a training path to grow the next techs. Choosing the mix is Plan work, the second of three stages (Organize, Plan, Grow) in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy. Start by counting the jobs a new person could do in month one. A business consultant helps you put real costs on both paths before you commit.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. The first 15-minute call costs nothing.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Bad Is the Shortage, Really?

The technician shortage means more trade jobs than trained people to fill them. Many techs are retiring or leaving, and too few new ones are coming in. Waiting for the perfect hire usually means waiting a long time.

Real World Help From Dr. Paul

Great Work, No One to Hire?

Pick the help that fits where your company is on hiring.

Best fit for this page

Business Consulting

Can’t find techs? Dr. Paul helps you plan the hire-or-train mix.

See business consulting

Business Plan Writing

Need a plan that shows a lender your hiring plan? Dr. Paul builds it for you.

How Dr. Paul writes plans

Business Plan Template

Building your own plan? The plumbing template lays out wages for helpers, apprentices and techs.

See the plumbing template

Small Business Education

Just starting? Learn how to hire the right person.

Read the free lesson

Starting a trade company? Plan who you’ll hire second, and how you’ll train them, before you open.

How This Guide WorksDoctor Owl advises the Fabled Forest’s business owners. The animals are invented; the job numbers are real. First, both options side by side. Then Tobin chooses between a hire he can’t afford and a helper he’d have to train. Tobin has more stories in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Choice

How Many Trade Jobs Need Filling in 2027?

A lot. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects about 40,600 openings a year for HVAC techs from 2025 to 2035, with jobs growing 11%, much faster than average.

Plumbing is close behind, with about 42,000 openings a year for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, BLS projects. Most plumbers learn through a four- or five-year apprenticeship.

Projected Openings Each Year, 2025 to 2035
Plumbers and pipefittersabout 42,000
HVAC techsabout 40,600

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook.

Side by Side

How Do Training and Hiring Compare?

Train your ownHire experienced
Cost to startLower pay at first, plus training timeHigher pay, often a signing bonus
Time to full speedMonths to yearsWeeks
RiskThey may leave once trainedThey may bring habits you don’t want
Best whenYou have a tech who likes to teachWork is waiting now and you need hands

Illustration only. Rough numbers to show the idea. Say a helper at $20 an hour lets a tech bill one more hour a day at $150. That’s $130 a day more in billed work than the helper’s pay.

Work through these 3 questions first.
  1. Which jobs could a helper do in the first month?
  2. Who on your crew would train them, and when?
  3. How much work are you turning down right now?

Not open yet? Plan your second hire, and the training path behind it, in your startup plan.

Manager, not the owner? A service manager can run the training plan. Pay rates and hiring decisions are the owner’s call.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Should Tobin Hire or Train?

The Helper Who Kept Asking

Tobin the Toad came to the Lone Oak with two notes. One was from an experienced plumber who wanted far more than Tobin paid anyone. The other was from a young helper from the marsh who kept asking to work with him.

Doctor Owl read both. “Is this a fire, or is this a foundation?” he asked.

“Foundation,” Tobin said. “We’re busy, not drowning. I just can’t find anyone.”

“What could the young one do in his first month?”

Tobin thought about it. Carry pipe. Stock the wagon. Clean up. Hand tools to his lead tech so she could finish faster.

So Tobin did both, carefully. He hired the young one as a helper with a one-page training plan. His lead tech would teach one new skill each month. He kept the job ad running for one experienced hire, at a price he could hold.

By fall, the helper was doing simple jobs on his own. The lead tech was billing more hours than ever.

“Tight as a toad’s seal,” Tobin said. “And I trained him myself.”

The lesson: the tech you need next year may be the helper you start training this year. With the team growing, the next stage is deciding what to grow into. See how to grow once your team can take on more.

Illustration only: A helper at $20 an hour who frees one billed hour a day at $150 adds about $130 a day.

In Practice

What Does a Helper’s First Month Look Like?

A written plan keeps a new helper useful and keeps your lead tech from feeling buried.

  1. Week one: Truck stock, tools, safety and riding along.
  2. Week two: Carrying, prep and cleanup on every job.
  3. Week three: Simple tasks under watch, like filter swaps or faucet prep.
  4. Week four: A short check-in on what they’ve learned and what’s next.
  5. Every month after: One new skill, signed off by the lead tech.

Put the plan on one page. Give a copy to the helper and the lead tech, and review it together every month.

Plenty of Work, Nobody to Send?

Owners who learned the trade the hard way often doubt they have time to teach it. Planning that time is the business side. See what Dr. Paul’s consulting covers, or bring your job ad and crew list to a free 15-minute call.

Book a Free 15-Minute Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a business consultant and author. He helps HVAC and plumbing owners build teams when hiring is hard. Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series is one of more than 90 books he has written for owners. He also holds a DBA from National University and an MBA with a focus in Finance from Webster University, and he has 1,000+ clients across the U.S. and Canada. Read more about Dr. Paul or see his author page on Amazon.

What Do Trade Owners Ask About Hiring Techs?

Is an apprentice worth the training time?

Often, if a good tech has time to teach. The payback comes in year two and beyond.

How do I find helpers?

Trade schools, high school programs, supply houses and your own techs’ friends and family.

What should a new company do first?

Hire one experienced tech, then add a helper once the work is steady.

What if I train someone and they leave?

Some will. A clear path to higher pay and lead tech keeps more of them.

Sources

Scroll to Top