Home › Who We Help › Coffee Shops and Bakeries › Keeping Baristas

How Do Coffee Shops Keep Baristas When Tips Drop?
Last spring your baristas made about $9 an hour in tips. Now it is closer to $7. Customers tap “No tip” on the screen more often, more orders come through the app and nobody can tell why the jar is lighter. Your best barista, the one who trained the last three hires, asked for more hours somewhere else. You cannot control what customers tip. You can control how tips are shared, what the base pay is, what the tip screen asks and whether a barista can see a future at your shop. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, a business consultant to more than 1,000 small businesses, helps owners build that.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do Coffee Shops Keep Baristas When Tips Drop?
Make tips fair and visible, lean less on them and give baristas a path to more pay. Post tips per hour every week. Share them by hours worked, with no owners or managers in the pool. Review the tip screen settings. Raise base pay with your next price increase, so less of the paycheck rides on tips. Then set clear steps, such as barista, senior barista and shift lead, each with a raise.
How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with tips per hour, then a story where Louie Waffles, the Labrador who runs Waffle Woofs Bakery & Café, opens the tip jar for everyone to see, three steps, Dr. Paul’s view, the tip screen and a pay path. More stories like Louie’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
Tips per Hour
How Should a Coffee Shop Share Tips?
Start with the law. Whether or not you take a tip credit, federal law bars employers, including managers and supervisors, from keeping any part of employees’ tips, per the U.S. Department of Labor. Owners and managers stay out of the pool.
| Posted every week, sample | This week | Last spring |
|---|---|---|
| Total tips | $1,820 | $2,370 |
| Barista hours | 260 | 260 |
| Tips per hour | $7.00 | $9.12 |
Example only. Split by hours worked, paid out on payday and posted where everyone can see it.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Louie Open the Tip Jar?
Doctor Owl was posting the library’s honey accounts on the board by the door, so every helper could see where the honey went.
Louie Waffles came in with his ears down. “My best helper, the young otter, is leaving,” he said. “She says the thank-you acorns are smaller now. And nobody knows how I split them.”
“How do you split them?”
“I count them at night. Then I give everyone some.”
“How many?”
“Whatever seems right.”
Doctor Owl tapped the board. “Your helpers cannot see what seems right.”
So Louie got a glass jar. Every week, he wrote on the wall how many thank-you acorns came in and how many hours everyone worked. Each helper got acorns by the hours they worked. Louie kept none for himself.
Then he paid every helper a little more each day, so the jar mattered less. And he made a ladder: helper, senior helper, morning lead. Each step came with more pay and a skill to learn.
The otter looked at the wall. “So if I learn to open the shop, I move up?”
“On the house,” Louie said, then caught himself. “No. You earn it.”
She stayed.
In the library, the helpers read the honey accounts every week.
The lesson: pay feels fair when everyone can see how it works and where it can go.
Louie Waffles and Waffle Woofs Bakery & Café are from the Fabled Forest. The lighter tip jar and the barista leaving for the chain are real.
What to Do
How Do I Make Barista Pay Steadier?
Steadying barista pay takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Pull six months of tips and hours. Work out tips per hour by month and by shift.
Write the tip pool rules and post tips per hour weekly. Review the tip screen settings and set a base pay target.
Set pay steps with skills for each. Raise base pay with your next price increase, and track who leaves and why.
Opening a coffee shop? Plan base pay and tip rules before your first hire. The coffee shop business plan template has a staffing section to build from.
Shift lead? Under federal law, a lead who mostly makes drinks and has no say in hiring and does not manage two full-time staff can usually stay in the tip pool. States set their own rules, so ask before you accept the title.
Dr. Paul’s Take
Baristas Leave Over Pay They Cannot Predict
When tips fall, owners feel helpless because they do not set tips. Dr. Paul points to what the owner does set: a fair pool everyone can see, a base wage that carries more of the load and a path to a higher rate. Baristas stay when they can count on their pay and see where it goes next. Building that pay plan is the work in Dr. Paul’s business operations consulting.
The Tip Screen
How Should a Coffee Shop Set Up Its Tip Screen?
- Check the preset choices; set amounts that fit a $3 drip and a $7 latte.
- Make “custom” and “no tip” easy to find, so the screen does not feel like pressure.
- Decide whether the screen appears for bakery-only or app orders.
- Look at tips by order type monthly to see what changed.
Pay Path
What Does a Barista Pay Path Look Like?
| Step | Skills to earn it | Base raise, sample |
|---|---|---|
| Barista | Full menu, register, cleaning standards | Starting rate |
| Senior barista | Dialing in espresso, training new hires | +$1.50 |
| Shift lead | Opening and closing, cash, scheduling help | +$3.00 |
Example only; each raise is added to the step before. If a lead truly manages staff, federal law takes them out of the pool, so set the raise to cover the lost tips.
What Else Do Owners Ask About Barista Pay?
Can I keep part of the tips to cover card fees?
Federal rules allow a few narrow cases, and several states do not. Check your state before you take anything from tips.
Can kitchen staff share in the tip pool?
It depends on whether you take a tip credit and on your state. Check both before you change the pool.
Should I switch to no tipping and higher prices?
Some shops do. Price the change carefully and tell customers why, and set base pay so baristas earn at least what they made with tips, or your best ones will leave.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He builds the tip rules, base pay targets and pay steps with you and tracks turnover monthly.
This is one of six guides for coffee shop and bakery owners. See them all on the Coffee Shops and Bakeries page.
First employee, now the lead? See the Durham business consultant page.
Steady pay helps keep the bake crew too. Here is moving the bake schedule so mornings start later.
What Were Your Baristas’ Tips per Hour Last Month?
Bring six months of tips and hours to a free 15-minute call. Dr. Paul builds barista pay plans in business operations consulting. Rates are on the pricing page.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Fact Sheet #15: Tipped Employees Under the FLSA.
