Home › Who We Help › Construction Companies › Hire and Keep Crews

How Do Contractors Build a Crew When Skilled Workers Are Scarce?
An ad that runs for a month. A new hire who does not show up on Monday. Another who quits by Wednesday. If that is your hiring year, you have company: construction firms report the same thing across the country. The industry is short on people, and small contractors compete with big jobs that pay more. So win on what you control. As a business consultant, Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, focuses owners on the first week, the people a new hire works beside and a clear path to the next pay step.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Find Good Construction Workers and Keep Them?
Find them through your own crew first: referrals with a bonus after 90 days, trade schools and pre-apprentice programs. Keep them by making the first week clear and safe: a named buddy, a first-day plan and a check-in by day three. Then show every worker a path: written skill steps, each with a pay raise attached, so they can see how to earn more without leaving.
How This Guide WorksHere you will find the size of the labor shortage, why new hires leave in the first days, a first-week plan, a skill and pay ladder, three steps and a story where Chuck the Chipmunk takes the new hires under his wing. More stories like Bella’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
The Shortage
How Short Is the Construction Workforce?
Very. Associated Builders and Contractors estimates the industry needs to attract about 349,000 net new workers in 2026 just to keep up with demand, according to Construction Dive.
Finding people is only half of it. In the 2026 AGC and NCCER Workforce Survey, 42% of respondents reported that new hires fail to show up or quit shortly after starting, and 88% of firms with craft openings said those jobs were as hard or harder to fill than a year earlier, according to the survey analysis.
Why They Leave
Why Do New Construction Hires Quit in the First Week?
- Nobody tells them what to do, so they stand around and feel useless.
- They are sent to a different site and crew every day.
- They do not get the gear or tools they were promised.
- Nobody asks how it is going until they have already decided to leave.
- Their hours get cut every rainy or slow week, with no warning.
- They cannot see how to earn more without going somewhere else.
A Sample
What Does a First Week and Pay Ladder Look Like?
| Day | First week plan |
|---|---|
| Monday | Hiring paperwork, safety talk and any required training, gear and tools, meet the buddy, then paid time on site |
| Tuesday and Wednesday | Work beside the buddy, same site and crew |
| Wednesday afternoon | Foreman check-in: what is going well, what is confusing |
| Thursday and Friday | One small task of their own, checked by the buddy |
| Step | Skills to show | Pay |
|---|---|---|
| Laborer | Safety basics, site cleanup, material handling | Starting rate |
| Helper | Basic tools, reading simple plans | First raise |
| Skilled tradesperson | Works alone on standard tasks | Second raise |
| Lead | Runs a small crew and trains new hires | Lead rate |
What to Do
How Do I Build a Hiring and Retention Plan for My Crews?
Building and keeping a crew uses the three stages of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Write a one-page first week: what the new hire does each day, who their buddy is, the safety talk and the tools you provide. Write a skill and pay ladder for your main roles.
Ask your crew for referrals and pay a bonus after 90 days. Contact one trade school or pre-apprentice program. Check in with every new hire on day three and day thirty.
Track who stays past 90 days, and why the others left. Ask your best workers once a year what keeps them, and act on one answer.
Writing next year’s staffing budget? Include referral bonuses, buddy time and the raises on your pay ladder. The construction company business plan template has a staffing plan to build from.
Foreman who trains new hires? Be the buddy on day one, or name who is. Your first-week plan matters more to the new hire than the owner’s.
Dr. Paul’s Take
The First Week Decides
Owners spend weeks finding a worker and five minutes starting them. Dr. Paul sees the result: new hires who stand around, feel lost and do not come back. A first day with a plan, a buddy who answers questions and a quick check-in costs almost nothing and keeps people past the week most quit. Building that first week and the pay ladder behind it is the work in Dr. Paul’s business operations consulting.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Bella’s New Hires Keep Disappearing?
“Gone by Wednesday,” Blueprint Bella the beaver said, sitting down hard on the church step. “Three new hires this month. Not one made it to Thursday.”
Doctor Owl had just finished walking a new young choir member through the hymnal, page by page. “What happened on their Monday?” he asked.
Bella thought. “I handed them a hard hat and sent them to whatever site needed hands.”
“Who did they ask when they did not know something?”
Bella did not answer. She did not know.
Back at the yard, Chuck the Chipmunk, her foreman, had an idea, though he waited until Bella asked him what he thought. “Give each new one a buddy,” he said around his screws. “Same buddy all week. Same site if we can. And somebody asks them on Wednesday how it is going.”
Bella wrote a first-week page: Monday, paperwork, safety talk and tools. Tuesday and Wednesday, work beside the buddy. Thursday, a small job of their own. On Wednesday afternoon, Chuck would ask how it was going.
She also wrote a ladder. Laborer, then helper, then framer, then lead, each with the skills to learn and a raise attached.
The next new hire, a young otter, stayed the week. And the next. By fall, he had climbed one step on the ladder and was showing the newest hire where the tools went.
“He asked me what it takes to make lead,” Chuck told Bella. “I showed him the page.”
The lesson: workers stay when the first week is clear and the next step up is written down.
The beaver, the chipmunk and the young otter come from an invented forest. The hire who is gone by Wednesday is not invented.
What Else Do Contractors Ask About Hiring Crews?
Where do I find construction workers?
Start with your own crew: referrals from good workers bring good workers. Add trade schools, pre-apprentice programs and local workforce boards.
How do I compete with bigger contractors on pay?
Pay as fairly as you can, and compete on what a small firm can offer: steady work, a clear path to raises, an owner who knows their name and less time away from home.
What should a new hire’s first day include?
A safety talk, the tools and gear they need, a named buddy and a clear plan for the day. Nobody should spend day one waiting to be told what to do.
I’m starting a construction company. How do I hire my first crew?
Hire one or two good people you know, write their first week and pay steps down, and add more as signed work grows.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He writes the first-week plan and skill and pay ladder with you, and sets up the check-ins and referral program that keep people.
You can find five more guides for construction owners on the Construction Companies page.
A South Carolina builder faced the same talent squeeze: see the Greenville, South Carolina business consultant page.
A deeper bench is what lets the owner step back. See how to run your construction company without doing everything yourself.
Fabrication shops are losing veteran welders to retirement; read a handoff plan for welders near retirement.
Tired of Hiring the Same Spot Every Month?
Finding workers is hard. Losing them in the first week makes it harder. Dr. Paul helps contractors build the first week and the ladder in business operations consulting. Bring your last five hires to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- Associated Builders and Contractors workforce estimate, as reported by Construction Dive, January 2026.
- Associated General Contractors of America and NCCER, 2026 Workforce Survey Analysis.
