Home › Who We Help › Home Care and Assisted Living › Keeping Caregivers

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do Home Care Agencies Keep Caregivers When Hospitals Pay More?

Your best caregiver gives two weeks’ notice. The hospital down the road hired her as a nursing assistant, with a set schedule, benefits and a raise. She liked her clients. She did not like never knowing how many hours she would get next week. Home care cannot match every hospital wage. But hospitals win on more than pay: steady hours, a path up and a schedule you can plan a life around. Agencies can compete on those, and business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, shows them how: guaranteed hours, the same clients every week and training the agency pays for.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Do I Keep Caregivers Who Could Earn More at a Hospital?

Compete on what hospitals offer besides pay. Guarantee a minimum number of weekly hours to caregivers who keep their availability. Keep the same caregiver with the same clients, so the work feels like their own. Pay for the next credential, such as home health aide, med tech or CNA, so the path up runs through your agency. Ask every caregiver at 30 and 90 days what would make them leave, since most decide well before they say so.

How This Guide WorksThis guide covers the pay gap with hospitals, a sample guaranteed-hours offer, what caregivers say they want, three steps and a story where a bear who runs the forest care home nearly loses her best helper to the big mill. More stories like the bear’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Pay Gap

How Much More Do Hospitals Pay Caregivers?

Enough to matter. Nursing assistants in hospitals earned a median of $42,310 a year in May 2025, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, or about $20.34 an hour full time. Home health and personal care aides earned a median of $17.21, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics. That is a gap of about $3 an hour.

Schedules widen it. Zingage’s 2026 caregiver survey found that 83% of caregivers whose schedules were disrupted every week had turned down shifts, and 45% decided to leave weeks before telling anyone, per Zingage. A caregiver with uneven hours earns less than her rate shows.

A Sample

What Does a Guaranteed-Hours Offer Look Like?

PieceSample offer
Hours floor30 paid hours a week for set availability
ClientsThe same three to five clients each week
Who gets itYour most reliable caregivers, as client hours allow
Training pathHome health aide, med tech or CNA tuition paid by the agency
RepaymentPro-rated, only where state law allows, never below minimum wage
Check-insStay interviews at 30 and 90 days, then yearly

What to Do

How Do I Build a Plan to Keep Caregivers?

Keeping caregivers takes three stages, in line with Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Pull each caregiver’s weekly hours for the last three months, how many different clients they saw and why the last five left. Ask your current team at 30 and 90 days what would make them leave.

2. Plan

Set a guaranteed weekly hours floor for your most reliable caregivers, only as many as your client hours can carry. Rebuild the schedule so each caregiver has steady clients. Price a training offer.

3. Grow

Offer the plan, starting with your best caregivers. Track turnover, hours variance and stay-interview answers every quarter.

Hiring your first caregivers? Plan guaranteed hours and a training path into your budget from the start. The home healthcare agency business plan template has a staffing plan to build from.

Care coordinator? Keep each caregiver with the same clients when you build the schedule. Moving people around to fill holes is how good caregivers decide to leave.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Hours You Can Count On Beat a Bigger Hourly Rate

Owners think they lose caregivers to a bigger hourly rate. Dr. Paul finds they often lose them to uneven hours. A caregiver getting 38 hours one week and 19 the next earns less than her rate suggests and cannot plan her rent. A guaranteed floor, steady clients and a training path cost less than replacing her, and she stops checking the hospital job board. Building that plan with you is the work in Dr. Paul’s strategic planning consulting.

Warning Signs

How Can I Tell a Caregiver Is About to Leave?

  • She turns down extra shifts she used to take.
  • Her hours have swung up and down for a month.
  • She keeps getting moved to new clients to fill holes.
  • She asks about the hospital’s nursing assistant class.
  • She stops speaking up at check-ins.

Zingage found 45% of caregivers decided to leave weeks before telling anyone. Any two of these signs means a stay conversation this week.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Did the Bear’s Best Helper Almost Go to the Mill?

The Big Mill

The big mill across the river had offered the miller’s apprentice more corn a week. He turned it down, and Doctor Owl wanted to know why.

“Here I know my work every day,” the apprentice said. “And the miller is teaching me to dress the stones.”

Doctor Owl was still thinking about it when the bear arrived. “My best helper is leaving for the big mill,” she said. “They pay more.”

“How many mornings did she work for you last month?”

The bear counted. Some weeks, six. Some weeks, two, when an old animal moved in with family. And the helper went to a different den nearly every day, wherever there was a hole.

“The mill pays more,” said Doctor Owl. “But I think the mill also lets her know her week.”

The bear went to see her helper that evening. She offered a promise of at least five mornings a week, whatever happened. The same three old animals every day, the ones who already asked for her by name. And the bear would pay for her lessons with the forest healer.

The helper thought about it for a night. Then she told the mill no.

The bear made the same offer to her other steady helpers. That year, only one left, and that one moved away.

The apprentice dressed his first millstone that autumn. Doctor Owl went to watch.

The lesson: caregivers stay for steady hours, steady clients and a way to grow, not just a bigger rate.

The bear and her helpers are from the Fabled Forest. The caregiver lost to a hospital schedule is real.

What Else Do Home Care Owners Ask About Keeping Caregivers?

Can I afford to guarantee hours?

Not for everyone. Set the floor below your average demand and offer it to the caregivers you most need to keep. When a client drops, their hours go to call-out coverage, covered in the call-out guide.

Why pay for CNA training when nursing homes train for free?

Because free training comes with a nursing home job. Paying for it here keeps the caregiver here. Some states restrict repayment agreements, so check with an employment attorney before asking for one.

Should I just raise pay?

Pay matters; in one 2026 survey, 44% of caregivers named it as the biggest thing that would help. Look at what turnover costs you, then sort out hours and schedule, then decide how much raise the rest of the plan lets you afford.

I’m opening a home care agency. How do I keep caregivers from the start?

Promise only what you can keep. A small guaranteed floor and steady clients from day one build a team that does not need replacing every year.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He builds the hours floor, the scheduling rule and the training offer with you, and prices them against what turnover costs you now.

Five more guides for home care and assisted living owners are on the Home Care and Assisted Living page.

A Massachusetts owner who could not afford raises kept his crew with steady routes and set days off: see the Springfield business consultant page.

Raises to keep aides have to come from somewhere. That is the subject of growing a home care agency without a cash squeeze.

Dental offices compete with hospitals and chains too. See keeping hygienists when larger employers pay more.

How Many Hours Did Your Best Caregiver Get Last Week?

Uneven hours push caregivers toward hospital jobs. Dr. Paul builds retention plans with home care owners in strategic planning consulting. Bring three months of caregiver hours to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Bring Your Caregiver Hours to a Free Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Keeping caregivers when bigger employers pay more is a regular topic for Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA. More than 1,000 small businesses in every state and Canada have worked with him. He holds an MBA in Finance from Webster University and a DBA from National University, and he wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top