Home › Who We Help › Restaurants › Staff Conflict

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Stop Restaurant Staff From Fighting With Each Other?

“The kitchen hates us.” “Servers never read the ticket.” Every restaurant has heard some version of that. In a small place it blows over. In a busy one, it turns into slammed plates, cold food and good people giving notice. Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has watched this play out in kitchens of every size, and the fight is rarely about personalities. It is usually about a broken handoff between the front and the back.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Do I Get the Front and Back of House to Stop Fighting?

Find the handoff where the fight starts. It is almost always one of three: how tickets get sent, how mistakes come back to the kitchen, or how tips and staff meals get shared. Hear each side alone, write one rule for that handoff with both leads in the room, and post it. Then hold everyone to it, including your favorites. Most restaurant fights end when the rule replaces the argument.

How This Guide WorksHere you get the signs a fight has turned costly, why short staffing makes it worse, a sample rule for the pass, three steps and a story where Fast Frankie the fox finds the real cause behind a shouting match. More stories like Frankie’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Signs

How Do I Know the Fight Is Costing Me?

  • The same kind of remake keeps coming back, rush after rush.
  • Servers and cooks stop speaking outside of tickets.
  • Guests can hear it from the dining room.
  • Someone has quit and named the other side.
  • You schedule people apart to keep the peace.

Why Now

Why Do Restaurant Teams Fight More When They Are Busy?

Because they are short. In 7shifts’ 2026 report on what restaurant employees want, understaffing ranked as workers’ top stressor, as Fast Casual reported. TouchBistro’s 2026 report found the average restaurant short five team members, according to Modern Restaurant Management.

A short crew has no slack. Every remake, missed change and slow ticket lands on someone who is already behind. People blame the other side because they can see it. The handoff that failed is harder to see.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Settle the Handoff, Not the People

Owners try to solve a staff fight by talking to the loudest person. Dr. Paul starts somewhere else: he watches the pass during a rush. The trouble usually sits in one spot where work changes hands, and both sides are right about it from where they stand. Change that spot and the shouting fades. Finding that handoff with you and settling it is the work in Dr. Paul’s conflict resolution consulting.

What to Do

How Do I End the Fight for Good?

Dr. Paul takes it in three stages, the same three in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Talk to one person from each side, alone, for ten minutes each. Ask the same question: “When does it go wrong?” Write down the moment both sides name.

2. Plan

Sit both leads down together with the notes. Agree on one rule for that moment and write it on one card. Decide what happens when the rule gets broken.

3. Grow

Post the card at the pass. Watch the next three rushes. Praise people who follow it out loud, and handle a broken rule the same way every time, no matter who broke it.

Not open yet? Set the rules for the pass, remakes and tip sharing before the first service, and train both sides together. The restaurant business plan template has a staffing section for it.

Kitchen or floor lead caught in the middle? Bring the owner the moment, not the names. “Remakes during the rush” gets an answer. “Chris is rude” gets a shrug.

A Sample

What Does a Rule for the Pass Look Like?

Changes: every change goes on the ticket. Spoken changes do not get cooked.

Remakes: the server brings the plate and the ticket to the kitchen lead, not to the cook.

During the rush: no comments about anyone’s work. Save it for the after-shift talk.

After the shift: both leads spend five minutes on what went wrong, and write one note.

Keep yours to four lines. A rule nobody can remember in a rush does not work.

Doctor Owl Teaches

What Did Fast Frankie Find Under the Shouting?

The Ticket That Wasn’t

Half the forest had heard about the fight at Fast Frankie’s. Doctor Owl heard it while calibrating his old kitchen scale with a sack of flour.

He stopped in during the dinner rush. At the pass, Nell the otter was holding up a plate and saying, very slowly, “This is the third remake tonight.”

Afterward Frankie threw up his paws. “Nell says the servers are careless. The servers say Nell is a grump. I like everybody. What do I do?”

“Watch the remakes,” said Doctor Owl.

For one week Frankie wrote down every plate that went back. Nine of twelve had the same story: a server took a change at the table, said it out loud to the line, and the cook never heard it over the fans.

“So nobody is careless,” said Frankie, “and nobody is a grump.”

“Everybody is shouting over the same fan,” said Doctor Owl.

Frankie sat Nell and the head server down together. They wrote one rule: every change goes on the ticket, or it does not get cooked. They posted it at the pass.

The next Friday there were two remakes. Nell held up one ticket, read the change written on it, and remade the plate without a word.

Frankie leaned over to Doctor Owl. “One card,” he whispered. “Two months of shouting I could have skipped.”

The lesson: most fights between teams are about a handoff, and a written rule settles a handoff faster than a speech.

The forest is fiction. The plate that comes back three times on a Friday is not.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Staff Conflict?

Should I just let them work it out?

Not when guests can hear it. A short, fair rule settles more than waiting does, and it protects the people who are doing the job right.

What if the problem really is one person?

Then treat it as a performance issue: the specific behavior, the standard and a date. The same rules apply to your best cook as to your newest busser.

Do tip-sharing rules cause fights?

Often. Rules on tip pools differ by state and by how your restaurant pays, so set them with your payroll provider or an employment lawyer, and post them in writing.

I’m opening a restaurant. How do I head this off?

Train front and back together in week one and walk the pass as a team, with the rules for the pass already written.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He interviews both sides, watches a rush with you and helps you write and roll out the rule.

Five more guides for restaurant owners are on the Restaurants page.

The same fight in a different city: see the Charleston, South Carolina business consultant page on staff conflict.

Staff who fight usually bring every dispute to the owner. See how to stop being the only one who solves problems in your restaurant.

Want Help Calming the Kitchen?

You can cook through a Friday rush. Settling a fight between your two best teams is a different skill. Dr. Paul brings it to restaurant owners in conflict resolution consulting. Bring a week of remakes to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Set Up a Free 15-Minute Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a business consultant to more than 1,000 small businesses in all 50 states and Canada. He studied at National University for his doctorate and at Webster University for his MBA in Finance. He writes Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. When teams fight, he looks at the handoff first. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Sources

Scroll to Top