Home › Who We Help › Salons and Barbershops › Star Stylist

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Handle a Great Stylist Who Causes Problems in My Salon?

Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, helps salon owners get ready for a talk that is easy to put off for months. It sounds like this. Your top stylist is booked six weeks out, and clients love her. She also shows up late, snaps at the newer stylists and rolls her eyes in team meetings. Two good people have hinted they are leaving. You say nothing, because her chair pays a lot of the rent. Cutting and color came with training. Holding your best earner to the house rules did not.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

What Do I Do About a Top Stylist Who Hurts the Team?

Decide what you expect from everyone and write it down. Then tell her plainly, in private, what has to change and by when. After that, follow through. Her talent is not the problem, and it is not a pass. It is tempting to wait, because she brings in so much. Waiting costs more. A team that leaves one by one costs the shop more than one chair, even a full one.

How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with Dr. Paul’s view on why the money argument runs backwards. Then come the numbers, the signs that it is time to act, three steps and a short script for the talk itself. At Swing Shift Barbers in the Fabled Forest, a made-up place with real business problems, Startup Steve the monkey faces the same choice with his fastest barber. More stories like Steve’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Her Chair Is Not the Whole Cost

Owners add up what a star stylist brings in and stop there. Dr. Paul adds the other column: the stylist who quit last spring, the assistant who cries in the back room, the hour the owner loses every week smoothing things over. Put both columns on one page and the choice gets clearer. The goal is not to push her out. It is to give her one fair chance to keep the chair and the team. Setting that standard and getting ready for that talk is the work in Dr. Paul’s conflict resolution consulting.

The Problem

What Does One Difficult Employee Really Cost?

A Harvard Business School working paper studied about 50,000 workers at 11 companies. It put the cost of one toxic worker at $12,489, mostly from other people quitting and the expense of replacing them. A performer in the top 1% added $5,303.

$12,489cost of one toxic worker, mostly from the co-workers who leave
$5,303added by a performer in the top 1%

Source: Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, on the 2015 paper Toxic Workers by Michael Housman and Dylan Minor.

The study is from 2015 and it was not about salons, so do not read those dollars as a quote for your shop. Read the direction: the damage ran more than twice the gain. In a salon that damage shows up as people leaving. Each stylist who goes takes clients along, and the chair sits empty while you hire. For one place stylists go when they leave, see the salon suites trend.

The fear on the other side is real too: she walks, and her book walks with her. Count all of it. Add up what her chair leaves the shop after her commission. Then add up what the shop keeps from the people who have hinted they are going. One standard does not make her leave. Silence makes the others leave.

Stylists have options. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects 5% job growth for barbers, hairstylists and cosmetologists from 2024 to 2034, faster than the average for all jobs. That is true for her, and it is true for the people she is pushing out. Nobody stays because the owner kept quiet.

The Signs

How Do I Know It Is Time to Act?

  • Two or more people on the team have complained about the same person.
  • You build the schedule around who can stand to work beside her.
  • You have bent a rule for her that you hold everyone else to.
  • A client has seen or heard her go after a co-worker.
  • A good stylist has quit, or hinted at it, and named her.
  • You dread the days she works.

Two or more of these, and waiting is the expensive choice.

What to Do

How Do I Set One Standard Without Losing My Best Stylist?

Dr. Paul works through this in three stages, the same three in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Write down what happened, with dates. Aim for three to five specific things, not “bad attitude.” Then write the house rules that apply to everyone: start times, how the team speaks to each other, what happens in meetings. If she rents her booth, read the booth renter question below first. You cannot set a renter’s hours.

2. Plan

Before the talk, decide what must change and by what date. Decide what happens if it does not: a written warning first, then parting ways. Ask yourself whether she has asked for something fair that you can offer. Pick a private time when neither of you has a client waiting.

3. Grow

Have the talk. Write down what you both agreed and check in every week for a month. Go over the house rules with the whole team that same week, so nobody is singled out. A team that sees one standard stays.

Hiring your first stylists? Write your house rules before you hire stylist number one, and hand them over with the offer. The hair salon business plan template has ownership and labor sections where your pay structure and rules belong.

Manager, not the owner? Keep the dated notes yourself and bring them to the owner with one request: back one standard for everybody.

The Talk

What Do I Actually Say to Her?

Do it in private, at a time when neither of you has a client waiting. Keep your part short. Here is a sample. The details are made up. Use your own.

Open with the truth: “You are one of the best stylists I have worked with, and I want you here.”

Name what happened: “Three times this month you came in after your first client was seated. On the 14th you criticized a co-worker’s foils in front of her client.”

State the standard: “Everyone here starts on time, and nobody gets corrected in front of clients. That includes me.”

Ask: “What is going on, and what do you need from me?”

Close with a date: “Here is what I need to see by the 30th. We will check in every Friday until then.”

If she says she will quit: “I hope you stay. The standard is the same either way.”

Then stop talking and listen. Write down what you both agreed before the first client arrives.

Doctor Owl Teaches

How Did Startup Steve Handle His Fastest Barber?

The Fastest Clippers in the Forest

Shouting came through the optician’s wall just as Doctor Owl’s reading glasses were being bent back into shape, after he had sat on them again. The shouting came from Swing Shift Barbers. He walked next door with the glasses crooked on his beak.

The shop’s newest barber, a young rooster with the fastest clippers in the forest, was telling Sorrel the hedgehog that her fades were “slow as sap.” Sorrel said nothing. She started packing her combs.

Startup Steve pulled Doctor Owl aside. “He does forty trims a Saturday,” Steve whispered. “Best clippers I ever hired. I can’t lose him.”

“How many barbers have you lost since he started?” Doctor Owl asked.

Steve counted on his fingers. One had left in the spring. Now Sorrel was packing.

“And what did you say to him the last time this happened?”

“Nothing,” Steve admitted. “I gave him the good chair by the window.”

That night Steve wrote three house rules on a card. Start on time. No remarks about another barber’s work in front of customers. Questions about a cut go to Steve. In the morning he sat down with the rooster before opening. He said the rooster was the fastest barber he had ever hired. He named the two things that had happened that week. He read the card aloud. Then he asked what the rooster needed.

The rooster was quiet for a long time. It turned out he wanted to teach. Nobody had ever asked him.

Steve did not promise it. “Keep to the card for a month,” he said, “and then we will talk about Tuesdays with the apprentice.” The rooster took the same card as everyone else.

Sorrel unpacked her combs. That Saturday her chair was full by nine, and the rooster held the door for her customers.

The lesson: talent earns the chair. It does not earn a different set of rules.

Illustration only. The rooster and the shop are invented; the choice between one chair and the whole team is real.

What Do Salon Owners Ask About a Difficult Top Stylist?

Should I let a top stylist go if she is hurting the team?

Not as the first move. Give one clear chance: what has to change, by what date, in writing. If nothing changes after that, letting her go protects the people who are doing it right. Treat her the way you would treat anyone else on the team, and talk to an employment lawyer before you act.

What if she rents a booth and is not my employee?

You have less say over how a booth renter works, and the rules differ by state. Rules about shared space and how people treat each other can still go in the rental agreement. Talk to an employment lawyer in your state before you change it.

How do I keep her clients if she leaves?

Plan before the talk. Know which of her clients have also seen other stylists in your shop. Rules about client lists differ by state and by contract, so check yours with a lawyer. Clients who like the shop, not just one chair, are the ones who stay.

I am opening a salon. How do I prevent this?

Write the house rules before the first hire and go over them in the interview. A stylist who objects to “nobody gets corrected in front of clients” has told you something useful early.

How does Dr. Paul help with a talk like this?

He helps the owner prepare the notes, the standard and the words, by phone, by Zoom or on site.

Salon owners have five more guides like this one, all listed on the Salons and Barbershops page.

The same problem shows up outside the salon trade. See the Cleveland, Ohio business consultant page on talented but difficult employees.

Losing one star can mean replacing her. Here is how to hire stylists and barbers who won’t leave for a suite.

Want Help Getting Ready for That Talk?

You can do a balayage with your eyes closed. Nobody taught you how to tell your best earner that the rules cover her too. Dr. Paul works with salon owners on exactly that in conflict resolution consulting. Bring your dated notes to a free 15-minute call and leave with a plan for the talk. If your notes show one bad week and not a pattern, that is what you will hear. Rates for anything past that call are on the pricing page.

Book a Free 15-Minute Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a business consultant and author. His doctorate is from National University and his MBA in Finance is from Webster University. He has worked with 1,000+ small businesses in all 50 states and Canada, and he writes Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. When the trouble is between people, he starts with what the owner has written down, not with who is right. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Sources

Scroll to Top