Home › Who We Help › Tree Service › Buying or Renting Equipment

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Should My Tree Service Buy a Bucket Truck or Rent a Crane?

Your climbers are tired. A bucket truck would save them on half the trims and speed up the removals. A used one is listed down the road. On the crane jobs, the rental company charges for setup, travel and a four-hour minimum, and it eats your bid every time. You could buy, rent, sub out the crane work or wait another year. Each choice is right for some tree services and wrong for others. Your own job list decides. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, a business consultant to more than 1,000 small businesses, works those numbers with tree service owners.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Should My Tree Service Buy a Bucket Truck or Rent a Crane?

Count the days you would really use it. Put a day rate for every machine on every bid, and pull last year’s jobs to see how many days a bucket truck or crane would have worked. Buy when your days clear the break-even between owning and renting, with room for slow months. Rent or sub out the crane, with its certified operator, until your crane days are steady.

How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with a break-even worksheet, then a story where the sharp-eyed woodpecker who runs a tree crew in the forest thinks about her own tall ladder, Dr. Paul’s view, three steps, buy, rent or sub out side by side and myths about tree equipment. More stories like the woodpecker’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Break-Even

How Many Days Make a Bucket Truck Worth Owning?

Used bucket truck, monthly, sampleAmount
Loan payment$2,600
Insurance$450
Upkeep, inspections and testing$300
Monthly cost of owning$3,350
Rental rate$550 a day
Break-evenAbout 6 days a month

Example only. If your jobs need the truck 10 days a month most of the year, owning saves money and climbers’ backs. If it is 4, rent. Fuel and the operator’s time cost the same either way. Add the down payment and expected resale value to the full comparison.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Should the Woodpecker Buy Her Own Tall Ladder?

The Borrowed Ladder

Doctor Owl was deciding whether to buy the library a tall ladder or borrow the beavers’ every time a high shelf needed dusting.

The sharp-eyed woodpecker was there to borrow it too. “My crew climbs every tree by claw,” she said. “A tall ladder would save their wings. And the beavers’ raft costs me a whole day every time, even for an hour of lifting.”

“How many days did you borrow the raft last year?” Doctor Owl asked.

She did not know. So that evening, she went through her bark notes, job by job. The ladder would have helped on about half the jobs, every moon. The raft, only a few times a season.

Tobias the turtle, who kept books for half the forest, helped her count. A ladder of her own cost about as much each moon as renting one for six days. She would use it more than that every moon, even in winter.

The raft was different. She used it only a few days a season. Renting it, with the beavers who knew how to steer it, was cheaper than owning.

She bought a used ladder and kept renting the raft. On every job, she wrote down what each one would have cost by the day.

In the library, Doctor Owl kept borrowing the beavers’ ladder. He only dusted twice a year.

The lesson: count the days you will really use a tool before you buy it.

The woodpecker, Tobias and the beavers are from the Fabled Forest. The four-hour crane minimum that eats your bid is real.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

A Day Rate on Every Bid Tells You When to Buy

Owners decide on equipment by how tired the crew is or how good the deal looks. Dr. Paul puts a day rate for each machine on every bid, even when renting. After a season, the bids show exactly how many days the shop needed it and what customers paid for it. That record makes the buy decision simple. Building the day rates and the break-even model is the work in Dr. Paul’s financial planning and modeling consulting.

What to Do

How Do I Decide on Big Tree Equipment?

Deciding on equipment takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Pull last year’s jobs. Count the days a bucket truck or crane would have worked, by month.

2. Plan

Price owning: payment, insurance, upkeep, a certified operator if needed and parking. Price renting by the day. Find the break-even days.

3. Grow

Buy if your days clear break-even in most months, including slow ones. Keep a day rate on every bid either way.

Not open yet? Rent the big equipment your first year and track the days. The tree trimming and removal business plan template has an equipment and financing section.

Crew lead? Mark every job where a bucket truck or crane would have saved time. That list is half the case for buying one.

Three Choices

Should I Buy, Rent or Sub Out Big Equipment?

Each machine has its own job. Aerial lifts should not be used as cranes to lift tree parts unless designed for that purpose, per OSHA, so a bucket truck does not replace a crane on heavy picks.

BuyRentSub out
Best whenYou use it most weeksA few days a monthA few days a season
CashPayment every monthOnly when usedOnly when used
OperatorYours, trainedYours, or with operatorTheirs
SchedulingAlways available, even after a hurricaneBook ahead; rentals vanish after big stormsTheir calendar

Myth and Reality

What Do Tree Service Owners Get Wrong About Equipment?

Myth: A bucket truck pays for itself. Reality: jobs pay for it, only if there are enough of them every month.

Myth: Renting is throwing money away. Reality: renting below break-even keeps cash for slow months.

Myth: Bigger equipment wins bigger jobs. Reality: crews and bids win jobs. Equipment helps you finish them.

What Else Do Tree Service Owners Ask About Equipment?

Should I buy new or used?

Used lowers the payment, but have the boom, hydraulics and dielectric rating inspected and tested. Check parts and service nearby.

Can I run a crane myself?

Use a qualified operator. Certification rules depend on whether OSHA treats the job as construction and on your state. Most tree services rent with an operator.

What about a compact lift or a grapple saw truck?

Run the same math: days used, day rate and what it replaces. Specialty machines need steady demand.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He builds the day rates and break-even model from your job list and tests the payment against slow months.

This is one of six guides for tree service owners. See them all on the Tree Service page.

Growing faster than your cash can keep up? See the Fargo business consultant page.

Steady work is easier to bid well. Here is a site walk and bid sheet for tree removals.

How Many Days Would a Bucket Truck Have Worked Last Year?

Bring last year’s job list to a free 15-minute call. Dr. Paul models equipment decisions with tree service owners in financial planning and modeling consulting. Rates are on the pricing page.

Count Your Equipment Days

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Behind Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, are an MBA in Finance from Webster University, a DBA from National University and more than 1,000 small business clients in all 50 states and Canada. He wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Sources

Scroll to Top