Home › Who We Help › Trucking Owner-Operators › Find Reliable Drivers

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do Small Trucking Companies Find Good Drivers?

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has heard the same story from fleet owners in every region: the ad said great pay and plenty of miles, ten people called, three showed up, one lasted a month. Big carriers spend heavily to recruit, and good drivers have choices. A two- or five-truck company wins a different way, with an ad that tells the truth, a screening process that follows the rules and a first month that makes the driver want a second one.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Does a Small Fleet Find Good Drivers?

Write a job ad with real numbers: pay per mile or per week, home time, the lanes and the truck. Drivers skip ads that hide them. Ask your best driver who they would trust, and pay a referral bonus after 90 days. Screen every applicant the same way: application, driving records, past employers, drug and alcohol checks and a road test. Then plan the first month: a ride-along, a walk through the first settlement and check-ins on day 3, 14 and 30.

How This Guide WorksFirst, why hiring drivers is getting harder, then what goes in a job ad, a screening checklist, the first 30 days, three steps and a story where Dumpster Dani’s ad gets plenty of calls and no drivers. More stories like Dani’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Driver Market

Why Is Hiring Truck Drivers Getting Harder?

Recruiting costs are higher, the driver pool is shrinking and pay competition is back heading into 2027, according to Heavy Duty Trucking. English-language proficiency enforcement and the federal non-domiciled CDL rule have removed drivers from the market; the compliance and capacity trend guide covers what that means for small fleets.

About 93% of the roughly 2,221,200 heavy and tractor-trailer drivers in the Bureau of Labor Statistics count work for an employer, not themselves. Every one of them is a driver a small fleet has to win away from someone.

The Job Ad

What Do Drivers Look for First in a Job Ad?

  • Pay, in real numbers: per mile, per load or per week.
  • Home time: nights out, weekends home, how often.
  • Lanes or area: regional, OTR, local.
  • Weekly miles, and detention and layover pay.
  • The truck: year, make, automatic or manual, governed speed.
  • Rider and pet policy.
  • Who dispatches, and how to reach them at night.

Screening

What Must I Check Before a Driver Starts?

Federal rules require a driver qualification file for each driver. The FMCSA checklist lists what goes in it. Check each applicant the same way:

  • A signed employment application.
  • Driving records from every state where they held a license in the last three years.
  • Safety history from their DOT-regulated employers in the last three years.
  • A pre-employment query in the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse, then one every year after, per FMCSA.
  • A pre-employment drug test, a valid medical certificate and a road test.
  • Enrollment in a drug and alcohol testing consortium for random tests.
  • Your insurer’s approval of the driver, before the first load. This is often the slowest step.

The First 30 Days

How Do I Keep a New Driver Past the First Month?

WhenWhat happens
Day 1Truck walk-around, paperwork, ride-along with your best driver
Day 3Owner calls: what is harder than expected?
First paydayWalk through the settlement line by line
Day 14Check-in on home time and dispatch
Day 30Sit-down: what to keep, what to change

What to Do

How Do I Build a Driver Hiring Process?

Hiring drivers who stay follows three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Write down the job as it really is: pay, home time, lanes, truck and who dispatches. Build your screening checklist from the federal driver file rules. Ask your drivers who they know.

2. Plan

Write the ad with the real numbers. Set a referral bonus paid after 90 days. Plan the first month: ride-along, settlement walk-through and the day 3, 14 and 30 check-ins.

3. Grow

Hire one driver at a time through the full checklist. Track where each good driver came from and spend more there. After each hire, ask the new driver what the ad got right and wrong.

Budgeting for your first hire? Include driver pay, payroll taxes, recruiting and a month of training miles. The trucking company business plan template has a staffing plan in its financial model.

Driver asked to help hire? Give the owner two names you would ride with. Your word is worth more than any ad.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Tell Drivers the Truth in the Ad

Owners write ads to get calls. Dr. Paul has them write ads to get the right calls. Put the real pay, the real home time and the real truck in the ad, and the drivers who would quit in week three never apply. The ones who do apply already know the deal. That is how a small fleet hires fewer people and keeps more. Building that hiring process with you is the work in Dr. Paul’s business operations consulting.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Did Dani’s Ad Bring Calls but No Drivers?

Great Pay, Lots of Miles

Dani slapped her notice onto the church board right beside the one Doctor Owl was pinning up, for a new choir pianist.

GREAT PAY! LOTS OF MILES! CALL DANI!

“Twelve calls last time,” Dani said. “Four came in. One drove a week and quit. Said the miles were too many and the pay was too little.”

Doctor Owl read her notice twice. “How much is great pay?”

Dani told him.

“Then why not write that?” He pointed to his own notice. It said Thursday evenings, Sunday mornings, the old upright piano, and the pay.

“Because then fewer will call.”

“Fewer of the wrong ones,” said Doctor Owl.

Dani went back to the yard and asked Rufus what he would want to know before taking the job. Rufus chewed on it until the next morning. Then he gave her a list: the pay per mile, how many nights out, which weekends home, and which truck.

Dani wrote a new notice with all of it. Six drivers called. Three came in. She checked each one the same way: records, past jobs, a drive with Rufus in the right seat.

She hired one. On his first day, Rufus rode with him. On the third day, Dani called. In the first week, she walked him through his pay sheet line by line.

A year later, he was still driving for Dani on the Run, and he had brought in his cousin.

The church found its pianist. She had asked about the piano first.

The lesson: an honest ad brings fewer calls and better drivers.

Dani on the Run hauls in the Fabled Forest. The driver who quits in week one hauls everywhere.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Finding Drivers?

Should I hire drivers fresh out of CDL school?

Some insurers will not cover drivers with less than one or two years of experience, so call your agent first. If they allow it, a new driver with a good trainer can become your best hire.

How much should a referral bonus be?

Many small fleets pay 500 to 1,000 dollars, after the new driver passes 90 days. Paying on day one rewards a hire, not a keeper.

Do I need a driver qualification file for every driver?

Yes, for drivers of commercial vehicles under federal rules. The FMCSA publishes a checklist of what goes in it and how long to keep each item.

I’m adding my first driver. What should I set up first?

Your screening checklist and your Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse account. Do both before you post the ad.

Trucking owners have five more guides like this one on the Trucking Owner-Operators page.

A New Hampshire owner hired with a paid trial run: see the Manchester business consultant page.

A good hire still needs a reason to stay. Read about giving drivers reasons to stay with a small carrier.

Towing companies hire under insurer rules too: hiring tow drivers your insurance will cover.

Want Drivers Who Show Up and Stay?

The right driver is out there reading ads. Yours should tell them the truth. Dr. Paul sets up the ad, the screening and the first month with fleet owners in business operations consulting. Bring your last job ad to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Bring Your Job Ad to a Free Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Small fleets that cannot keep a seat filled often end up talking with Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA. He has advised more than 1,000 small businesses in all 50 states and Canada, holds an MBA in Finance from Webster University and a DBA from National University, and is the author of Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top