Home › Who We Help › Welding and Fabrication › Buying a Machine

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Should My Fabrication Shop Buy a Machine or Outsource the Work?

Every week you send plate out to be cut. The outside shop does good work, but it takes ten days, and twice this year it took three weeks and you lost a job. The salesman says a plasma table pays for itself in a year. Or it sits half the week while the payment comes due every month. A machine is a big promise. Before you make it, the numbers should say yes. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, runs those numbers with fabrication owners, drawing on work with more than 1,000 small businesses.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Should My Fabrication Shop Buy a Machine or Outsource the Work?

Buy when your own numbers show the monthly cost of owning, including the payment, operator time, consumables, power and upkeep, is lower than what you spend outsourcing, or when outside lead times are costing you jobs. Pull 12 months of outsourcing invoices first. Count how many hours a month the machine would really run. Then decide on the cash payment, not on the tax write-off.

How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with a monthly cost comparison, then Dr. Paul’s view, a story where Silas the Salamander of Salamander Seam Works considers his own press, three steps, what to check before you buy and three myths about equipment. More stories like Silas’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Own or Outsource

Does Owning a Machine Cost Less Than Outsourcing?

Plasma table, monthly, sampleOutsourceOwn
Outside cutting invoices$3,800
Loan payment, 60 months$1,650
Consumables and power$450
Operator, 30 hours at $25.84 plus 20% payroll costs$930
Upkeep$150
Monthly cost$3,800$3,180

Example only. Owning saves about $620 a month at this volume and cuts lead time from weeks to days. If outside work drops to $2,000 in a slow month, owning costs more. The operator rate is the 2025 BLS median for welders and cutters; use your own numbers.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

The Tax Write-Off Does Not Make the Payment

Owners hear “write it all off this year” and sign. Dr. Paul reminds them the deduction lowers taxes once; the payment comes every month for five years. A machine makes sense when the shop has the work to keep it busy and the cash to carry it in a slow month. Building that model, with the payment, the work and the slow months, is the work in Dr. Paul’s financial planning and modeling consulting.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Should Silas Buy His Own Cutting Table?

The Printer Next Door

Doctor Owl was deciding whether to buy the library its own printing press or keep sending pages to the printer in the next village. The press was beautiful. It was also very large.

Silas the Salamander was looking at it too. “The beavers cut all my iron sheets,” he said. “They take two weeks. A peddler offered me my own cutting table. He says it will pay for itself by spring.”

“How many sheets do you send the beavers each moon?” Doctor Owl asked.

Silas did not know exactly. So he asked the young newt to count the bark receipts from the past year.

Some moons he sent a lot. Some moons, almost nothing. The table would cost him shells every moon, busy or not. And someone would have to run it instead of welding.

But twice that year, the beavers had been so slow that the badgers took their gate job elsewhere.

Silas did the math with Tobias, who kept books for half the forest. In a busy moon, the table saved shells. In a slow moon, it cost more than the beavers. Over a year, it came out a little ahead, and it would have kept the badgers’ job.

He bought a smaller, used table, so the slow moons would not hurt.

At the library, Doctor Owl decided to keep the printer next door. He did not print enough pages to keep a press busy.

The lesson: buy the machine when your own work keeps it busy, not when the salesman says it will.

Silas, the young newt, Tobias and the beavers are from the Fabled Forest. The two-week wait on outside cutting is real.

What to Do

How Do I Decide on a New Machine?

Deciding on a machine takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Pull 12 months of outsourcing invoices and lead times. List jobs lost or late because of outside work.

2. Plan

Price the machine, financing, operator time, consumables, power, space and training. Compare the monthly cost to outsourcing.

3. Grow

Test the slow month: can the shop make the payment when work drops by a third? Decide, then track machine hours monthly.

Equipping a new shop? Outsource cutting and forming until your volume proves the machine. The welding and fabrication business plan template has an equipment and financing section.

Shop lead? Log every part sent out and how long it took to come back. That record is what decides the next machine.

Before You Buy

What Should I Check Before Buying Shop Equipment?

  • Power, compressed air and fume extraction: does your building have them, or what does the upgrade cost?
  • Space and material flow around the machine.
  • Who runs it, and what they stop doing.
  • Training, nesting or CAD software and service support nearby.
  • Taxes: for 2026, the Section 179 limit is $2,560,000, phasing out above $4,090,000 of purchases, per UWorld. Confirm with your CPA.

Myth and Reality

What Do Shop Owners Get Wrong About Buying Equipment?

Myth: It pays for itself. Reality: the work pays for it, only if the work is there every month.

Myth: Bigger is better. Reality: buy the size your work needs. A smaller used machine carries a slow month.

Myth: We will find work for it. Reality: buy for the work you have, not the work you hope for.

What Else Do Shop Owners Ask About Buying Equipment?

Should I buy new or used?

Used equipment lowers the payment and the risk. Have it inspected, and check parts and service support in your area.

How does Section 179 work for a new machine?

It can let you deduct the full cost in the year it is placed in service, within limits and your business income. Bonus depreciation can also apply. Ask your CPA before you buy; it changes taxes, not the payment.

Should I lease or finance?

Compare the total cost and what you own at the end. A lease can lower the payment; financing builds equity. Run both.

Can I sell machine time to other shops?

Sometimes, and it can fill slow weeks. Do not count on it in the numbers that justify the purchase.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He builds the buy-or-outsource model from your invoices and tests the payment against a slow month.

This is one of six guides for welding and fabrication shop owners. See them all on the Welding and Fabrication page.

Old equipment and rising repairs? See the Lafayette business consultant page.

A good quote still needs the job out on time. Read a shop board that gets fabrication jobs out on time.

What Did You Spend on Outside Work Last Year?

Bring a year of outsourcing invoices to a free 15-minute call, and Dr. Paul will help you compare. He models equipment decisions with shop owners in financial planning and modeling consulting. See rates on the pricing page.

Run the Machine Numbers

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Owners weighing a big equipment purchase often call Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA. He holds an MBA in Finance from Webster University and a DBA from National University, has advised more than 1,000 small businesses in all 50 states and Canada and wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top