Home › Business Consultant › Ohio › Cleveland

What Do I Do About a Top Performer Who Upsets the Team?
Every Cleveland shop has one: the top producer who brings in the most work and the most trouble. Others tiptoe around them, and two good people have already quit. Big employers compete hard for skilled staff, so owners fear losing the star more than the damage. Spotting talent is easy for you. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, coaches owners to hold that star to the same rules as everyone else.
Handle an employee who does good work but causes problems by treating behavior as part of the job. Describe the specific behavior and its effect on the team, set a clear expectation and a short timeline and follow through. Praise the results and correct the conduct separately. Stage 1 of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, Organize, covers roles. A consultant helps you plan the talk.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Handle an Employee Who Does Good Work but Causes Problems?
Results are half the job. How someone treats the team is the other half. Name the behavior, not the person. Say what it costs the team. Agree on what changes, and by when. Keep praising the good work. If nothing changes, act. One star is not worth three good people walking out.
Real World Help From Dr. Paul
Great Results, Bad Behavior?
Pick the help that keeps the talent and protects the team.
Business Consulting
Plan the conversation and the follow-up for a talented but difficult employee.
See conflict resolution consultingBusiness Plan Writing
Taking over the family business? A plan values it before you sign.
See business plan pricingBusiness Plan Template
Each template’s management section spells out how the team works together.
Browse the templatesSmall Business Education
Want the bigger picture? A free lesson explains workplace culture.
Read the free lessonTaking over a family business? See how a Cleveland plan values the family business before you take it over.
How This Guide WorksStart with why Cleveland owners put up with difficult stars, then a five question check on your own situation. A Doctor Owl story follows. The gym in it is invented; a gifted trainer who drives everyone else away is common. Gus learned that his calm way of coaching worked on his star too. More stories wait in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
Watch Dr. Paul
Organize-Plan-Grow your Small Business | Dr. Paul Borosky, MBA.
Organize-Plan-Grow starts with clear roles, including how people work together. Dr. Paul explains the approach.
What Is Happening
Why Do Cleveland Owners Put Up With Difficult Stars?
Big employers compete for the same talent. Cleveland Clinic alone has more than 48,000 employees and calls itself the largest private employer in Northeast Ohio, according to its own figures.
Small firms cannot match that pay or those benefits. So when an owner finds a skilled person who delivers, they tolerate a lot. The cost shows up elsewhere: quieter meetings, slower handoffs and good people who leave without saying why.
Keeping a star who hurts the team is not loyalty. It is a trade, and the owner sees the full price only when the resignations arrive.
Quick Check
Is Your Star Costing More Than They Bring?
Five questions about the person you are thinking of.
- Do coworkers avoid working with this person?
- Has anyone quit or asked to move because of them?
- Do you change plans to avoid upsetting them?
- Have you skipped a needed talk because of their results?
- Would the team feel relief if they were gone?
What Do Your Answers Mean?
Four or five yes answers: the cost is already high. Hold the conversation this week.
Two or three: name the behavior now and set a clear expectation before it grows.
One or none: keep coaching. Praise results and correct small slips quickly.
Not open yet? Opening soon? Write down how your team treats each other before you hire. Values on paper are easier to enforce. An industry business plan template has a management section to start from. Owners getting ready in Lakewood, Parma or Shaker Heights can book the free call too.
Manager, not the owner? If a star on your shift is wearing the team down, tell the owner with specific examples. Facts move owners faster than complaints.
Doctor Owl Teaches
How Did Gus Handle His Star Trainer?
Doctor Owl arrived for a massage he swore he would never book. Gus the Gorilla was waiting in the lobby, calm as ever, but rubbing his temples.
“My best trainer at Gorilla Grounds fills every class,” Gus said. “Members love her. But she snaps at the other trainers, takes their time slots and two of them just quit.”
Doctor Owl winced as the masseuse found a knot. “This knot came from one bad habit, repeated. What have you said to her?”
“Nothing. She’s too good to lose.”
“And the two who quit?”
Gus sat quietly for a long moment. The next morning he met his star trainer in private. He praised her classes, then named two behaviors and what they cost the team. They agreed on a shared schedule and a check-in in two weeks. She bristled, then she listened. Two weeks later the other trainers were laughing in the break room again.
The lesson: a talented but difficult employee changes when the owner names the behavior, sets a clear expectation and follows through. See how Dr. Paul helps owners with difficult top performers.
Gorilla Grounds trains members only in the Fabled Forest. Cleveland owners managing a gifted but difficult employee work from Ohio City to Tremont.
Dr. Paul has seen a difficult star become a team leader once someone finally told them how they came across. Book the free 15-minute call.
What Should a Cleveland Owner Do This Week?
Four steps toward a healthier team.
- Write two behaviors. Specific, not general.
- Note the cost. What the team loses.
- Hold the talk. Private, this week.
- Set a check-in. Two weeks out.
Which Free Resources Help Cleveland Owners?
Two free sources for Ohio owners; neither is connected to Dr. Paul.
- Ohio Small Business Development Centers: No-cost advising for Ohio owners, including the Cleveland State University office, on people and management.
- SCORE mentoring: Volunteer mentors who have managed talented, strong-willed staff.
Which Cleveland businesses struggle with difficult stars?
Gyms and fitness studios, salons, restaurants, sales teams and trades crews. The 2027 outlook for salons goes further.
How does Dr. Paul help Cleveland owners with a difficult star?
Dr. Paul plans the conversation with you on Zoom, down to the first sentence. He is based in Central Florida and helps you review the two-week check-in.
What Do the Other Ohio City Pages Cover?
Each Ohio page takes on a different owner problem.
Dr. Paul’s Insight
The Team Is Watching What You Allow
Owners think the difficult star is a private matter between them and one employee. Dr. Paul reminds them that everyone is watching. When bad behavior gets a pass because of good numbers, the team learns that results buy exceptions. Holding the star to the same standard tells everyone else their effort matters too.
Ready to Keep the Talent and the Team?
Write down two things your star does that wear the team down. Bring them to a free 15-minute call, and Dr. Paul will help you plan what to say. Finding talent is your skill; leading it is the business side. Services are listed on Dr. Paul’s consulting services page.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
What Do Cleveland Owners Ask About Difficult Top Performers?
How do I handle a good employee with a bad attitude?
Name the specific behavior, explain its effect on the team and set a dated expectation.
Should I keep a top performer who hurts the team?
Only if the behavior changes after a clear, fair chance.
How do I talk to a difficult employee?
Privately, with specific examples, praise for results and a clear request.
What if the behavior does not change?
Follow through on the next step you described, even if results are strong.
Can a consultant help with a difficult employee?
Dr. Paul plans the conversation and the follow-up with you. The pricing page has his fees.
What Should a Cleveland Owner Read Next?
Sources
- Cleveland Clinic, About Cleveland Clinic careers (more than 48,000 employees; largest private employer in Northeast Ohio).

