Home › Who We Help › Roofing and Remodeling › What Each Job Made

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Know What Each Roofing Job Really Made?

You bid it at 30 squares, one layer, a clean deck. You found two layers, six sheets of soft decking and a dumpster that filled by noon. The supplement for the decking came through. The second layer never got asked for. A month later the job is closed, and nobody knows if it made money. Most roofers only find out at tax time, when the year is already gone. A one-page square report for every finished roof, set up with business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, changes that, so the next bid reflects what the last roof really cost.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Do I Find Out What Each Roof Made?

Fill out a one-page square report within a week of finishing every roof. Compare the bid, or the adjuster’s scope on insurance roofs, to the actual job on the same lines: squares, layers torn off, sheets of decking, crew hours, dump fees, materials and supplements asked for and won. Divide the gross profit by the squares to get gross profit per square, before overhead and sales commission. Every month, look at which kinds of roofs and which surprises cost you most, and change your bid sheet to price them.

How This Guide WorksThis guide covers what roofing costs are doing in 2026, a sample square report, the surprises to track, three steps and a story where a badger roofer finds out his steep roofs paid less than his flat garages. More stories like the badger’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Costs in 2026

Why Do Roofing Bids Drift From Real Costs?

Because materials keep moving. GAF announced a 6% to 9% price increase on shingles and roofing accessories effective June 1, 2026, citing raw material and transportation costs, in a letter to customers. Verisk’s 2026 U.S. Roof Report found roofing material costs rose 1.48% in 2025, faster than roofer labor at 0.79%, with sharp regional swings, per Verisk. A price per square set last spring can be wrong by fall. See the tariffs and material costs trend guide.

A Sample

What Does a Square Report Show?

30-square roofBidActual
Revenue, including supplements won$13,500$14,450
Materials$4,800$5,200
Labor (second layer found)$3,600$4,500
Dump fees$400$700
Decking, 6 sheets$0$540
Gross profit (before overhead and sales commission)$4,700$3,510
Gross profit per squareabout $157$117

Supplements won: decking (600 dollars) and drip edge (350 dollars). Never asked for: the second layer. That one line was most of the gap. On insurance roofs, run the same report against the adjuster’s scope, not your own bid.

What to Do

How Do I Start Tracking Profit on Every Roof?

Finding out what each roof made takes three stages, in the order of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Make a one-page square report with the bid and actual side by side. Have each lead record layers, decking sheets and crew hours on the roof, with photos.

2. Plan

Fill out the report within a week of every finished roof, including supplements asked for, won and missed. Review the last month’s roofs on the first Monday.

3. Grow

Change the retail bid sheet: add lines for second layers, decking per sheet and dump fees. On insurance roofs, put steep, high and second-layer lines in every supplement.

Bidding your first roofs? Build the square report into your process from the first roof. The roofing contractor business plan template has a financial section for job costing.

Estimator or office manager? Keep the square reports in one place and show the owner the ten most recent every month. Patterns show up fast.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Bid From the Last Roof, Not the Last Price

Roofers bid from habit: last year’s price per square, plus a little. Dr. Paul has them bid from the last ten roofs instead. When the square reports show second layers cost you on every older home, you price a second layer in the bid and ask for it in every supplement. The report takes ten minutes and pays for itself on the next bid. Setting up the square report and the monthly review with you is the work in Dr. Paul’s business profitability consulting.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Did the Badger’s Steep Roofs Pay Less Than His Garages?

The Square Report

The badger roofer leaned on the garden fence while Doctor Owl weighed the potatoes he grew against the seed and water bill, as he did every fall.

“Busiest year I ever had,” the badger said. “And the account is thinner than last year.”

“Which roofs made money?”

The badger opened his mouth and closed it. “All of them, I thought.”

Doctor Owl held up a potato. “I thought so too, about the blue ones. Then I weighed them.”

That night the badger made a page: bid on one side, actual on the other. Squares, layers, decking, crew hours, dump fees, supplements won and missed. He filled one out for each of his last ten roofs from his leads’ notes and photos.

The simple low-pitch garages, the jobs he thought were small, made the most per square. The tall old houses on the hill made the least. Every one had a second layer he had not bid, steep slopes that slowed the crew, and decking he had replaced without asking the insurer to pay for it.

He changed his bid sheet that week: a line for a second layer and a price per sheet of decking, and steep and high-roof lines in every supplement. On the next hill house, he asked for the second layer in the supplement. It came through.

At the end of the next season, he had fewer roofs and more money.

Doctor Owl planted fewer blue potatoes. They had been eating the water bill.

The lesson: a roof is not profitable until the square report says so, so compare every bid to what really happened.

The badger and his roofs are fiction. A busy year with a thin account is not.

Warning Signs

How Can I Tell a Roof Is Losing Money Before It Is Done?

  • A second layer shows up at tear-off and is not in the bid or the supplement.
  • Decking sheets pass the allowance, with no photos to back them.
  • The dumpster fills before lunch and a second haul gets ordered.
  • The crew is still on the roof on day two of a one-day job.
  • Nobody has asked for drip edge, starter or flashing in the supplement.

Any one of these goes on the square report the day it happens, not a month later.

What Else Do Roofers Ask About Job Costing?

How long does a square report take?

Ten to fifteen minutes per roof, if your leads record layers, decking and hours on the roof. Without those notes, it takes an hour and is mostly guesses.

What is a good profit per square?

It depends on your market, your overhead and your mix of insurance and retail work. Start by comparing your own roofs to each other; the gaps tell you where to look.

Should I track supplements separately?

Yes. Track what you asked for, what was approved and what you never asked for. Missed supplement items are profit you did the work for and did not collect.

I’m starting a roofing company. Do I need job costing right away?

From the first roof. It is far easier to start with a square report than to rebuild a year of jobs from memory.

There are six guides for roofing and remodeling owners. Find the rest on the Roofing and Remodeling page.

A Texas owner tracked real costs against every bid: see the Houston business consultant page.

Job costing tells you what each job made; cash flow tells you if you can wait for the next storm. Read how roofing companies manage cash between storm seasons.

Do You Know What Your Last Ten Roofs Made?

A busy year can still be a thin one. Dr. Paul sets up square reports and bid sheets with roofers in business profitability consulting. Bring your last ten bids and invoices to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Bring Ten Roofs to a Free Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, asks roofers for their last ten roofs before he talks about prices. A business consultant to more than 1,000 small businesses in the U.S. and Canada, he earned a DBA at National University and an MBA in Finance at Webster University, and wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top