Home › Current Small Business Issues › Payroll Costs

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Afford Raises Without Losing My Profit?

Can you say yes to the raise and still make money? Your best employee has earned it, and the shop down the road is paying more. Payroll is already your biggest bill. The answer sits in how your trade pays people and where the paid hours go. Three trades show three versions of it below. The guide comes from Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, who helps owners run the numbers before they answer.

Stage 2 of 3: Plan

You afford raises by getting more out of the hours you already pay for. This is a Plan stage decision in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, the second of its three stages. You have the facts. Now you choose how to staff, schedule and pay. A business consultant works out the full cost of each position and shows where overtime and wasted hours can fund better pay.

Want to talk it through? (321) 948-9588. The first 15 minutes are on Dr. Paul.

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Can I Pay People More and Still Make Money?

Look at where the paid hours go. Some pay for work a customer buys. Some pay for waiting, redoing and overtime. Shrink the second pile and you free up money for raises. Paying well works when the hours are well used.

Doctor Owl comes from Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest series, where he advises the forest’s business owners. This answer is the real one, said simply.

The Full Answer

What Are the Steps to Afford a Raise?

Work through these steps before you answer the raise request.

  1. Find the full cost of the role. Add payroll taxes, time off and training to the wage.
  2. Match staffing to demand. Put more people on at your busy times and fewer during slow ones. Most schedules are built on habit.
  3. Cut overtime you did not plan. Track why each overtime hour happened for two weeks. A few causes will explain most of it.
  4. Stop paying for do-overs. A short checklist at the end of each job costs less than sending someone back.
  5. Then decide on the raise. If the savings cover it, say yes. If they cover part, offer a smaller raise now and a date to review.

What This Means for Your Business

How Does Payroll Pressure Differ From One Business to the Next?

A wage is only part of what a person costs. Add payroll taxes, time off, training and the hours when there is nothing to do. The pressure is the same everywhere. The shape of it is not.

In pet grooming

The fight is over the pay plan. Commission rewards speed. Hourly pay rewards showing up. Pick the wrong one and a busy week can pay your groomers well and leave the shop with nothing. The guide on paying groomers by commission or by the hour starts with what each groom has to cover.

In a daycare

Ratios set a floor on staffing, so you cannot cut your way out. The waste hides at the edges of the day. Rooms are staffed for a full house at open and close, when half the children are not there. See scheduling staff to meet ratios without overstaffing.

In a salon or barbershop

The most expensive person on payroll is often the owner. Every hour you spend on the schedule, the ordering and the payroll is an hour you are not behind the chair. A manager costs money. So does doing a manager’s job yourself. The guide on taking fewer clients or hiring a manager works through it.

A groomer’s raise is a pay-plan question. A teacher’s raise is a scheduling question. A salon’s payroll question may be about the owner’s own time. Know which one you have before you answer anyone.

What to Measure

Which Payroll Benchmark Matters for My Trade?

Every business can track labor cost as a percent of sales: total payroll divided by total sales for the same period. Watch it month to month. If it climbs while sales hold steady, hours are leaking. Then add the benchmark your trade runs on.

TradeBenchmark to watchHow to read it
Pet groomingWhat one groom must cover before payAdd supplies, card fees, bather and front desk time, rent and your profit target, then divide by grooms. Subtract that from the price of a groom. What is left is the most you can pay per dog. For a pay reference, median pay for animal caretakers was $35,360 a year in May 2025, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
DaycaresPaid teacher hours per enrolled child, each weekCount children by the half hour and staff to the count. The national health and safety standard, Caring for Our Children, recommends no more than four toddlers per teacher. Your state sets the legal number.
Salons and barbershopsHours of owner work left undone each weekList the jobs and the hours. If the total is large, compare it to what a manager costs: median pay for first-line supervisors of personal service workers was $48,590 in May 2025, per O*NET OnLine.

Notice that none of these is the wage itself. A groomer’s number is what the service has to earn. A daycare’s is hours against children. A salon’s is the owner’s own time. Get that number first and the raise decision gets much easier.

For any other trade, compare the hours you paid last week to the hours a customer paid for. The gap is where a raise can come from.

How a Business Consultant Can Help

How Does Financial Planning and Modeling Help You Afford Good People?

A raise is a decision about next year’s money, so the service that fits is Dr. Paul’s financial planning and modeling. It builds a budget and a simple model so you can see the money coming and test a decision before you commit to it.

Dr. Paul begins by gathering your real numbers and putting income, costs and cash in one place, so you can see what each part of the business earns. From there he builds a budget you can follow and a simple what-if model, plus a few key numbers to look at each week. After that, you use the model before big moves and compare budget to actual results every month.

Here is how that looks in each trade.

  • Pet grooming: the model runs commission, hourly and mixed pay plans against a busy day and a slow day, so you see what each plan leaves the shop.
  • Daycares: the model ties staffing to the hourly headcount in each room and shows what a staggered schedule frees up for wages.
  • Salons and barbershops: the model puts a manager’s pay next to the sales the owner gives up by leaving the chair, and shows the break-even.

This service is for running the business. It is not a set of projections for a lender. Sessions happen on site or over Zoom.

A practical deliverable

A budget you can follow, a simple what-if model and a few key numbers to review each week.

Current signal: the rank for payroll costs this month is on the top 10 small business problems countdown.

Start Here

What Should I Do Before Anything Else?

Pick one normal week. Add up the hours you paid and the hours a customer paid for, and write down the gap.

Not open yet? Budget the full cost of each worker, not just the hourly wage. The labor section of a business plan template walks you through it.

Running the place for someone else? You likely control the schedule. Run the one-week comparison and show the owner the gap.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

A Raise Is a Decision. Make It With Numbers

There are two bad answers to a raise request: a quick yes out of fear, or a quick no out of habit. Both skip the math. Find out what the role brings in and what it costs. Then decide, and be ready to explain why.

What Should I Read Next?

Related issue: why qualified workers are hard to find. See all ten issues on the current small business issues countdown.

Sources

Trade details come from Dr. Paul’s industry guides, linked above. Featured trades change monthly.

The facts are above. The fable starts here.

How Does a Fabled Forest Pizzeria Pay for a Raise?

A Fabled Forest Story: Frankie, Marco and the Quiet Hours

Doctor Owl was waiting on a pizza and watching the wall clock over the ovens. It was mid-afternoon. Six of Fast Frankie’s crew stood around one customer.

Frankie shot past with three boxes. “Two minutes! I’ve always got two minutes… tomorrow.”

So Doctor Owl asked Marco the Marten instead. “Marco, how many of the crew do you need at this hour?”

Marco jingled his ring of keys. “Two. Maybe three.”

“And at supper?”

“Eight. We run it with six and pay late hours every night.”

Marco already had it on paper. He owned the schedule. He had just never been asked.

“Leave it with me, Boss,” Marco told Frankie that night. Then he moved the hours. Fewer paws in the quiet afternoon, more at supper, no late hours. The pay total came out lower. Frankie used the difference to give his oven crew the raise they had been hinting at.

He even stood still for almost a full minute to tell them.

The lesson: move the hours to where the work is, and the raise can pay for itself.

More stories like Frankie’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Illustration only. Frankie and Marco live in the Fabled Forest. Overstaffed slow hours are real.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Payroll Costs?

What is a healthy labor cost percent?

It depends on the industry. A restaurant and a consulting firm look nothing alike. Compare yourself to your own past months first, then to trade benchmarks.

Should I give raises or bonuses?

A raise is permanent. A bonus rewards a result. Many owners use a modest raise plus a bonus tied to something the worker controls.

I am writing my first budget. How much should I plan for payroll?

Plan the wage plus taxes, time off and training. Then add slow-season hours, because you will pay them.

Good at the Job. Unsure About the Payroll Math?

You know which of your people are worth more. What you may not have is a clear picture of whether the business can carry it. Dr. Paul helps owners who came up through the work build a staffing plan that pays good people fairly. Try the one-week comparison first. More help is listed under his consulting services, with rates on the pricing page.

Start With a Free 15-Minute Call

Or reach him at (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is also the author behind Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. National University awarded his DBA, and Webster University awarded his MBA in Finance. His client list tops 1,000 small businesses in 50 states and Canada. His payroll reviews look at hours before wages. Meet Dr. Paul or find his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top