Home › Industry Trends › Trucking Industry Trends › Protecting Your Loads From Fraud

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do Small Carriers Protect Themselves From Freight Fraud in 2027?

The email looked right. The logo, the signature, the rate confirmation. Then the real broker called asking where the load was. Thieves now pose as carriers, brokers and shippers, and a small carrier with no office staff is an easy door in. Business Consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, puts it simply: a few habits, written down and followed every time, close most of those doors.

Stage 1 of 3: Organize

Verify every new broker and shipper through a phone number you look up yourself, never one from the email, and never change payment details without a call. Writing those checks down is Organize work, the first step in Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, which then moves to Plan and Grow. Start with your next new broker. A business consultant can help you write a one-page check that anyone in your office can follow.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Where Does Most Freight Fraud Happen?

On spot freight, the one-time loads booked off load boards, often in a hurry. Thieves post fake loads, pose as real brokers or pose as real carriers to pick up freight. Speed is their friend. A two-minute call to a number you looked up yourself is yours.

Real World Help From Dr. Paul

One Bad Email Away From a Lost Load?

Pick the help that fits where your trucking business is on fraud.

Best fit for this page

Business Consulting

Worried about fake brokers or payment scams? Dr. Paul helps you write the steps your office follows every time.

See SOP consulting

Business Plan Writing

Need a plan that shows a lender or insurer you manage risk? Dr. Paul writes it with you.

How Dr. Paul writes plans

Business Plan Template

Prefer to plan it yourself? The trucking template includes a section for your operating policies.

See the trucking template

Small Business Education

Want to see why one missing payment hurts so much? Read the QBP lesson on cash flow.

Read the free lesson

Just starting out? Write your verification steps down before your first load, not after your first scare.

How This Guide WorksIn the Fabled Forest, a made-up place, Doctor Owl advises animal owners. The fraud data on this page is real. First comes the 2027 trend, then a five-question check of your own habits. Then Dumpster Dani nearly hands a load to the wrong truck. Dani shows up again in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Trend

Is Freight Fraud Getting Worse for Small Carriers?

The thefts are fewer but bigger. Verisk CargoNet counted 547 cargo theft incidents in the third quarter of 2026, down 33% from a year earlier, but the average loss rose about 72% to $448,456, Verisk reported. Fictitious pickups, where a thief poses as a real carrier, made up roughly one in four incidents, FleetOwner noted.

Thieves are also buying their way in. Earlier this year, CargoNet warned that criminal groups were buying legitimate carriers with long, clean histories so they could pass broker checks, Insurance Journal reported. That makes small carriers both a target and a disguise.

Cargo Theft, Q3 2026 vs Q3 2025
Average loss per theftup about 72%
Number of theftsdown 33%

Source: Verisk CargoNet, third-quarter 2026 analysis (November 4, 2026).

Quick Check

Would Your Office Catch a Fake Load?

Answer yes or no. Be honest. Nobody’s grading this but you.

  • Do you look up a new broker’s phone number yourself instead of using the one in the email?
  • Does a payment change always need a phone call to a known contact?
  • Do drivers know never to hand freight to a truck not on the paperwork?
  • Is your carrier login protected with two-step sign-in?
  • Is there a written list of these checks that a new hire could follow?
What your answers mean.
  1. All yes: Your habits are strong. Review them with every new hire.
  2. One or two no: Pick the first no and write the step down this week.
  3. Three or more no: Start with payment changes. A redirected payment can cost more than a stolen load and is the easiest to stop.

Not open yet? Set up your email, carrier logins and payment accounts with two-step sign-in before you haul a single load.

Manager, not the owner? A dispatcher can run the broker and pickup checks. Approving any payment change is the owner’s call.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Did Dani Almost Hand a Load to the Wrong Truck?

The Second Truck at the Dock

Dumpster Dani was loading crates at the forest mill when a second truck pulled up. The driver waved a rate confirmation with her company’s name on it.

“Dani on the Run sent me,” the driver said. “Load it up, we’re in a hurry.”

Doctor Owl watched from the fence post. “Is this a fire, or is this a foundation?” he asked.

“Fire,” Dani said. “Somebody is trying to take my load right now.”

She did not argue with the driver. She walked to the mill’s office and called the broker using the number she had looked up herself the first time she worked with them.

The broker had never heard of the second truck. The mill’s shipping manager closed the dock door, and the second truck drove off fast.

That night, Dani wrote down every check she had just done on one page and taped it inside both trucks.

On the second day, Rufus read the page twice and added one line at the bottom: never trust a phone number in an email.

The lesson: check every new name through a number you found yourself, because the fake ones look exactly like the real ones. With your loads and pay protected, the next step is choosing how much freight to lock in. See how much of your freight to lock into contracts.

Illustration only: One phone call to a number you looked up yourself can stop a stolen load before it leaves the dock.

In Practice

How Do You Write a One-Page Fraud Check?

Write it in plain words. It takes about 30 minutes and should fit on a single page.

  1. New broker: Look up the company and call a number you found yourself.
  2. Rate confirmation: Match the email address, the authority number and the contact.
  3. Pickup: Drivers confirm the load number with the shipper before loading.
  4. Payment change: No change without a call to a contact you already know.
  5. Something feels off: Stop, call the office and wait.

Post the page in the office and in every truck. The check only works if everyone runs it the same way every time.

Afraid of the Load That Never Arrives?

Plenty of careful carriers have been fooled once. A short written check, followed every time, is the best defense a small office has. See what Dr. Paul’s consulting covers, or bring your current steps to a free 15-minute call.

Book a Free 15-Minute Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a business consultant and author. He helps small carriers write simple checks that stop fraud before it costs them a load. Owners in all 50 states and Canada, 1,000+ of them, have worked with him. He earned his DBA at National University and his MBA with a focus in Finance at Webster University, and he wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Read more about Dr. Paul or see his author page on Amazon.

What Do Carriers Ask About Freight Fraud?

How do fake brokers find me?

Usually through load boards and public records. A real-looking email is easy to make.

What is a fictitious pickup?

A thief poses as a real carrier, shows up with fake paperwork and drives away with the freight.

Can someone steal my payments?

Yes, by asking the broker to send your pay to a new account. Never change payment details without a phone call.

Should I report a scam attempt?

Yes. Tell the real broker and the shipper, and report it to the FMCSA.

Sources

Scroll to Top