Home › Business Consultant › Indiana › Indianapolis

What Do I Do About an Employee Who Is Not Doing the Job?
Patience keeps a lot of Indianapolis teams together. It also keeps the employee who is late again and cuts the same corners. With unemployment at 3.4 percent in 2025, owners hold on to weak staff just to fill the schedule, then redo the work after close. A clear, kind standard helps everyone, including that employee. Business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, coaches owners through the conversation.
Stop being too nice to an employee who underperforms by writing down what good work looks like. Meet privately within a day of a miss and set a short, dated plan to improve. Follow through on what you said. Stage 1 of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, Organize, covers clear roles. A consultant helps you plan the words and the steps.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Stop Being Too Nice to Employees Who Underperform?
Kindness is telling people the truth in time. Write down what a good shift looks like. When it slips, talk in private that same week. Name the gap, agree on a date to improve and write it down. Check in on the date. If nothing changes, act. Your good workers are watching what you allow.
Real World Help From Dr. Paul
Carrying a Weak Performer?
Pick the help that sets a fair standard and sticks to it.
Business Consulting
Write clear job standards and plan the conversation that comes next.
See SOP and organization consultingBusiness Plan Writing
Running a food truck? A plan shows how you get through the slow winter months.
See business plan pricingBusiness Plan Template
Each template lists job roles you can turn into written standards.
Browse the templatesSmall Business Education
Need the right words? A free lesson covers feedback on poor performance.
Read the free lessonRunning a food truck through winter? See how an Indianapolis food truck plans its cash for slow February sales.
How This Guide WorksFirst, why Indianapolis owners keep weak performers, then a five play routine for setting the standard. After that comes a Doctor Owl story. The cleaning company in it is invented; the owner quietly redoing a helper’s rooms after hours is common. Mavis learned that a clear talk saved the helper and her weekends. More stories wait in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
Watch Dr. Paul
COO Services for Small Business: Strategy, Organizational Structure & KPI | Dr. Paul Borosky, MBA.
Clear roles and simple measures make the hard talks easier. Dr. Paul walks through structure and KPIs for small teams.
What Is Happening
Why Do Indianapolis Owners Hold On to Weak Staff?
Workers are scarce. The Indianapolis metro unemployment rate averaged 3.4 percent in 2025, close to its 3.7 percent average in 2024, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED.
With few people looking for work, a weak employee feels better than an empty shift. The cost hides in rework, unhappy customers and good staff who grow tired of carrying someone else.
The Playbook
How Does an Indianapolis Owner Set the Standard and Keep It?
Five plays over the next thirty days.
Write what good looks like.
Three to five standards for the role, in plain words.
Why it matters: People can only meet a standard they can see.
Talk within a day.
Meet privately the day after a miss, not at the annual review.
Why it matters: A fresh example is hard to argue with.
Agree on a dated plan.
One change, one date, written down and signed by both of you.
Why it matters: A date turns a talk into a commitment.
Check in on the date.
Show up when you said you would and look at the work together.
Why it matters: Follow through is where most owners slip.
Decide and act.
Praise the improvement or move to the next step you described.
Why it matters: The rest of the team learns what your words mean.
- Every role has written standards.
- Misses are discussed within a day.
- Improvement plans have dates.
- You stopped redoing work after close.
- Your best people stopped complaining about one coworker.
Not open yet? Opening soon? Write the standards for each role before your first hire, so expectations start on day one. An industry business plan template lists the roles to start from. Owners getting ready in Carmel, Fishers or Greenwood can book the free call too.
Manager, not the owner? If you lead a shift, ask the owner for the written standards. Then you can coach to the page instead of to your own mood.
Doctor Owl Teaches
How Did Mavis Finally Have the Talk?
Doctor Owl was drying dishes while Mrs. Owl-Willow washed when Mavis the Mouse tapped at the kitchen window. Her kerchief was crooked and she looked tired.
“I go back to clean rooms my helper already cleaned,” Mavis said. “Every Saturday. She’s sweet and the customers like her. I can’t bear to say anything.”
Mrs. Owl-Willow handed Doctor Owl a plate with a streak still on it. He held it up, raised an eyebrow and passed it back without a word. She laughed and rinsed it again.
“See?” said Doctor Owl. “No hurt feelings. Just a clear plate. Does your helper know what a clean room looks like at Whisker Clean?”
Mavis thought about it. She had never written it down. That week she made a one-page checklist for a finished room and sat with her helper on Monday. They agreed on two weeks to get it right.
The helper was relieved. Nobody had ever shown her the corners Mavis cared about. By the second Saturday, Mavis stayed home.
The lesson: an honest, private talk with a clear standard and a date helps both the owner and the employee. See how Dr. Paul helps owners set clear job standards.
Whisker Clean scrubs only Fabled Forest homes. Indianapolis owners stuck with a struggling employee work from Fountain Square to Broad Ripple.
Dr. Paul has seen owners keep a struggling employee and turn them into a solid one, once the standard was finally written down. Book the free 15-minute call.
Dr. Paul’s Insight
Silence Is Also a Message
Owners stay quiet to avoid hurting someone. Dr. Paul has seen what the team hears instead: the standard does not matter here. The weak performer keeps slipping, and your strongest people start to wonder why they try. Speaking up early, in private and with a clear plan, is the kind choice for everyone, including the person who is struggling.
What Are Four Quick Moves for Indianapolis Owners?
Four steps toward a fair, clear standard.
- Write the standard. Three to five lines.
- Book a private talk. This week, not next month.
- Set one date. One change, one deadline.
- Put it on the calendar. Then show up.
What Free Help Is There in Indianapolis?
Two free sources for Indiana owners; neither is connected to Dr. Paul.
- Indiana Small Business Development Center: No-cost advising through the Central Indiana office, including team and management questions.
- SCORE mentoring: Mentors who have managed staff and handled the hard talks.
Which Indianapolis businesses carry weak performers longest?
Cleaning companies, restaurants, salons, retail shops and small trades crews. The 2027 outlook for cleaning companies goes further.
How does Dr. Paul coach Indianapolis owners through this?
Dr. Paul writes the standards with you on Zoom and helps you plan the talk, word by word. He is based in Central Florida and checks in after the follow-up date.
What Do Other Indiana City Pages Cover?
One more Indiana city and its owner problem.
Business consultant pages near Indianapolis
Ready to Have the Talk You Keep Putting Off?
Write down what the employee does well and the one thing that keeps slipping. Bring that short note to a free 15-minute talk. Dr. Paul will help you plan the conversation and the follow-up. Your patience built the team; a clear standard keeps it strong. Services are listed on Dr. Paul’s consulting services page.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
What Do Indianapolis Owners Ask About Underperforming Employees?
How do I stop being too nice to a weak employee?
Write the standard, talk privately within a day of a miss and set a dated plan.
What should I say to an underperforming employee?
Name the specific miss, describe what good looks like and agree on a date to check progress.
How long should I give an employee to improve?
Two to four weeks for one clear change is fair for most roles.
When is it time to let someone go?
When the plan is clear, the help is given and the work still does not change.
Can a consultant help with a problem employee?
Dr. Paul helps you set standards and plan the talk. See the pricing page for current fees.
Which Pages Should an Indianapolis Owner Read Next?
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED, Unemployment Rate in Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN (MSA) (3.7 percent in 2024; 3.4 percent in 2025).

