Home › Industry Trends › Trucking Industry Trends › Keeping Insurance Costs in Check

Why Is Truck Insurance Still Going Up in 2027?
Crashes are down. Your record is clean. And the renewal still came back higher. For a one-truck operation, that letter can feel like a punishment you did nothing to earn. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, tells owners the premium is coming either way. The part they control is whether the money is already waiting when the bill shows up.
Treat insurance and repairs as per-mile costs, set money aside every week, and start renewal shopping 90 days early with a clean safety file. Planning for the big bills is Organize work, the opening stage of Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy, followed by Plan and Grow. Begin with your last renewal letter. A business consultant can show you what insurance and repairs cost per mile and how much to move into savings each week.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. The first 15-minute call is on the house.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do Truckers Save for Big Bills Without Getting Caught Short?
They keep a maintenance reserve, a separate account that gets a set amount for every mile driven. The same idea works for insurance. When the tire, the brake job or the renewal comes due, the money is already there, and the truck keeps rolling.
Real World Help From Dr. Paul
Renewal Letter Made Your Stomach Drop?
Pick the help that fits where your trucking business is on insurance and repairs.
Business Consulting
Premiums and repairs swallowing the profit? Dr. Paul helps you plan for both before they arrive.
See profitability consultingBusiness Plan Writing
Need a lender to see you planned for insurance? Dr. Paul writes the plan with you.
How Dr. Paul writes plansBusiness Plan Template
Prefer to plan it yourself? The trucking template’s Excel model spreads insurance across the months.
See the trucking templateSmall Business Education
Not sure which costs stay steady and which move with miles? Read the QBP lesson on cost types.
Read the free lessonJust starting out? Get three insurance quotes before you buy the truck, not after.
How This Guide WorksIn the Fabled Forest, a made-up place, Doctor Owl advises animal owners. The cost data on this page is real. First comes the problem, then the habit that softens it. Then Dumpster Dani learns why the renewal letter did not have to be a crisis. Read more about Dani in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
The Problem
Why Do Premiums Keep Climbing When Crashes Fall?
Insurance cost carriers 10.6 cents a mile in 2025, up 3.9% in a year and up 23.9% since 2021, ATRI reported. Repairs and maintenance rose faster, up 8.6% to 21.5 cents a mile. Early 2026 data showed insurance up another 6.4%.
Large court verdicts and costlier repairs push premiums up for everyone, including carriers with clean records. And for a small carrier, falling behind on a premium has a harsh result: a lapsed policy means a revoked operating authority, FreightWaves noted.
Source: ATRI, Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking, 2026 update.
Neither cost is going back down soon. The carriers who handle them best treat them like diesel: a cost that comes with every mile, paid a little at a time.
The Solution: Save by the Mile
How Do You Stay Ahead of Insurance and Repairs?
Work out what each one costs you per mile, then move that amount into a separate savings account every week. When the renewal arrives, compare it with what you saved. Start shopping the policy 90 days early, with your safety scores, inspection reports and driver records ready to send.
- Divide last year’s premium by last year’s miles.
- Open a separate account just for insurance and repairs.
- Set a calendar reminder 90 days before the policy ends.
Not open yet? Get real insurance quotes for your truck, cargo and lane before you buy anything. New carriers often pay the most, and the quote can change the whole plan.
Manager, not the owner? An office manager can keep the safety file and track policy dates. Choosing the policy is the owner’s call.
Illustration only. A made-up fleet, for the example. Say your truck runs 110,000 miles a year and insurance costs 10.6 cents a mile. That is about $11,660 a year, or about $970 a month to set aside.
Example only: 110,000 miles a year.
Doctor Owl Teaches
Why Did Dani’s Renewal Letter Feel Like a Crisis?
Every year the same thing happened. The insurance letter arrived, the number was higher, and Dumpster Dani scrambled to find the money.
This year, Rufus brought the mail in on the second day and set the envelope on the desk with the others.
Doctor Owl was waiting out the rain under the awning. “Is this a fire, or is this a foundation?” he asked.
Dani thought about it. The policy was still good for two months. “Foundation,” she said. “It happens every single year. I just never get ready for it.”
So she took last year’s premium and divided it by the miles the trucks had run. Then she did the same with the repair bills.
She opened a separate account at the forest bank. Every week, she moved a little money in for every mile Dani on the Run had driven.
Two months later, the new premium was due. It was higher again. This time the money was already sitting there.
Dani shopped the policy anyway, early, with her inspection reports in one folder. The forest had more insurers than she remembered.
The lesson: save for insurance and repairs a little with every mile, because the bill always comes and the timing never helps. With the big costs covered, the next step is making sure your loads and your pay reach the right hands. See how to protect your loads and your pay from fraud.
Illustration only: Setting aside a few cents for every mile can turn a dreaded renewal letter into a routine payment.
What Can You Do About Insurance This Month?
An office manager can handle moves 1, 2 and 3. Moves 4 and 5 belong to the owner.
- Work out the per-mile cost. Premium and repairs, each divided by miles.
- Gather the safety file. Inspections, scores and driver records in one folder.
- Check every policy date. Know when each one renews.
- Open the savings account. Move the per-mile amount weekly.
- Shop the renewal early. Ask for quotes 90 days out.
In Practice
How Do You Build an Insurance and Repair Fund?
It takes one bank visit and about 20 minutes of math.
- Find last year’s totals: Insurance paid and repair bills, from the bank statement.
- Divide by miles: Each one becomes a cents-per-mile number.
- Open a separate account: Keep this money away from the operating account.
- Transfer weekly: Miles driven that week times the per-mile number.
- Check it at renewal: Compare the balance with the new premium.
If the balance falls short, raise the per-mile amount. The point is to find out early, not on the day the payment is due.
Clean Record, Rising Premium?
Plenty of careful owner-operators get the same bad news at renewal. You cannot set the premium, but you can plan for it. See what Dr. Paul’s consulting covers, or bring your last renewal letter to a free 15-minute call.
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
What Do Truckers Ask About Insurance Costs?
Why did my premium rise with a clean record?
Premiums reflect the whole market, including court verdicts and repair costs. A clean record helps, but it cannot stop the trend.
When should I shop my policy?
About 90 days before it ends. That leaves time to compare quotes and gather documents.
What happens if my insurance lapses?
Your authority can be revoked, and brokers will stop booking you. Do not let it lapse.
How much should I save for repairs?
Start with last year’s repair bills divided by miles. Raise it as the truck ages.
Sources
- American Transportation Research Institute, Operational Costs of Trucking 2026, via FleetOwner (July 2026).
- American Transportation Research Institute, Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking: 2026 Update (July 2026).
- FreightWaves, Why New Capacity Isn’t Entering the 2026 Freight Market (October 2026).
