Home › Who We Help › Auto Repair Shops › Advisors and Recommended Repairs

How Do I Get My Service Advisors to Sell Recommended Repairs?
Nearly half of car owners say seeing photos or videos makes them more willing to approve recommended work, according to Cox Automotive’s 2026 study. Yet most advisors still call and read a list: front pads, rear rotors, a leaking valve cover, two tires. The customer hears a bill and says, “Just the oil change.” In more than 1,000 client engagements, business consultant Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has taught advisors to show the problem, sort it by urgency and let the customer choose.
Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.
Last Updated: November 2026
Doctor Owl in Plain English
How Do I Get Customers to Approve More Recommended Repairs?
Send a photo of every recommended repair, sort the list into three groups (safety now, soon, watch) and offer the safety item first. Give one price per group, not a long list of line items. Write down every declined item and call about it before the customer’s next visit. Customers approve what they can see and what they are not rushed into.
How This Guide WorksThis guide covers what customers say makes them approve work, a sample now, soon and watch list, a call script, three steps and a story where Imani the Impala stops reading lists to customers. More stories like Imani’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.
What Customers Say
Do Photos Really Help Customers Approve Repairs?
Yes. In Cox Automotive’s 2026 Fixed Ops and Ownership Study, 49% of consumers said seeing photos or videos makes them more willing to approve recommended services, according to Cox Automotive. The same study found customers who received photo or video documentation spent about 640 dollars per repair order, against about 410 dollars for those who did not, as Collision Repair Magazine reported. Bigger jobs tend to get more photos, so read that gap as a link, not proof.
Those numbers come from dealer service departments, not independent shops. The point carries over: customers trust what they can see. For more on inspection tools, see the digital vehicle inspections trend.
A Sample
What Does a Now, Soon and Watch List Look Like?
| Group | Example items | How the advisor says it |
|---|---|---|
| Safety now | Front pads at 2 mm, leaking brake line | “This one I would not drive on. Here is the photo.” |
| Soon | Rear tires at 4/32, cracked serpentine belt | “These can wait a few weeks. I can book them with your next oil change.” |
| Watch | Valve cover seep, wiper streaks | “Nothing to do today. We will check again next visit.” |
Dr. Paul’s Take
Showing Beats Selling
Owners think their advisors need to be pushier. Dr. Paul rarely sees that work. Customers push back when they feel sold. They say yes when they see the worn part, understand the risk and get to choose the timing. The advisor’s job is to make that easy. Building that process and the words around it is the work in Dr. Paul’s sales and pricing strategy consulting.
What to Do
How Do I Train My Advisors to Present Repairs Well?
Dr. Paul trains advisors in three stages, matching Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.
Make photos part of every inspection. Each recommended item gets a picture and one plain sentence from the tech: what is wrong and what happens if it waits.
Have the advisor sort every list into safety now, soon and watch. Write a short call script and practice it out loud with each advisor. Set a rule: every declined item goes into the customer’s record with a follow-up date.
Track approvals by advisor for four weeks. Listen to a few calls each week and coach one thing at a time. Call declined work before it turns into an emergency.
Writing your yearly sales plan? Put your approval rate and declined-work follow-up in it as numbers to watch. The auto mechanic business plan template has a sales section for both.
Service advisor yourself? Try the three-group list on your next ten calls. Bring the results to the owner; numbers make a better case than a new script.
On the Phone
What Should an Advisor Say When Calling About Repairs?
Open: “Your car is done with the inspection. I just sent you a few photos. Do you have them in front of you?”
Safety first: “The first photo is your front brakes. That one is a safety item. The price to replace them today is on the text.”
Soon and watch: “The next two can wait. I can book them with your next visit, or do them today if that is easier.”
Close: “What would you like us to do today?”
Practice it until it sounds like your advisor, not like a script.
Doctor Owl Teaches
How Did Imani Stop Hearing “Just the Oil Change”?
Imani the Impala had the phone on one ear and a clipboard of repair orders in her hoof when Doctor Owl came by to write birthday cards for his three nephews at her counter.
“Seven items,” she said after the call. “Pads, rotors, a valve cover, two tires, a belt, a wiper. And she said, just the oil change. They all say that.”
“What did she hear?” asked Doctor Owl.
Imani thought. “A very long bill.”
“Then give her something shorter to hear.”
That afternoon Imani asked the techs for a photo of every item. She split the list into three rows: safety now, soon and watch. The next customer got a text with three pictures of brake pads worn to the metal and one price.
He called back in four minutes. “I can see the pad is gone,” he said. “Do the brakes. What was the soon list again?”
Ruben the Rhino leaned on the counter. “What did you tell him?”
“Nothing,” said Imani. “Let me show you, not tell you.”
By the end of the month, Imani had a list of declined items with a call date beside each one. The first three calls brought in two brake jobs and a belt.
The lesson: customers approve what they can see and are free to choose.
Imani works the counter on the savanna edge of the invented Fabled Forest. The customer who says “just the oil change” is not.
What Else Do Owners Ask About Advisors and Upselling?
I’m opening a shop. What should my advisor process look like on day one?
Photos on every inspection, a three-group list and a written call script. Starting that way is far easier than changing habits later.
How does Dr. Paul help?
He builds the inspection and call process with you, writes the scripts and reviews the approval numbers with your advisors.
Is selling recommended repairs the same as upselling?
Not when the work is needed. Telling a customer the brakes are worn is service. Pushing work the car does not need is the thing that loses customers, and photos keep everyone honest.
Should I pay advisors commission on approved work?
Many shops do. Pair any commission with a rule that every recommendation has a photo, so pay never pulls ahead of what the car needs.
What do I do about declined work?
Record every declined item with a date and call before the next service or when the item reaches the safety group. Declined work is future work if you keep track of it.
Auto repair owners have five more guides like this one on the Auto Repair Shops page.
Selling without pushing comes up outside auto repair too: see the Lancaster, Pennsylvania business consultant page.
An advisor can sell the job and still lose the day to a late part. See how to stop cars sitting in bays waiting on parts.
Want Your Counter to Hear Yes More Often?
Your techs find the work. Your advisors decide whether the customer ever sees it. Dr. Paul helps owners close that gap in sales and pricing strategy consulting. Bring a week of declined work to a free 15-minute call. His rates are on the pricing page.
Bring Your Declined List to a Free Call
Or call or text (321) 948-9588.
Sources
- Cox Automotive, 2026 Fixed Ops and Ownership Study, press release.
- Cox Automotive 2026 Fixed Ops and Ownership Study, as reported by Collision Repair Magazine.
