Home › Who We Help › Coffee Shops and Bakeries › Busy but Not Profitable

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Why Is My Busy Coffee Shop Not Making Money?

From 6:30 to 9:00 the line never stops. Three baristas, two grinders running, the pastry case half empty by 8. Then the afternoon comes. The same three baristas are wiping counters between a few customers an hour. And the free oat milk swaps and extra shots you hand to regulars add up quietly all day. At month end, the bank account looks like a slow shop’s. Busy and broke is a numbers problem, and it hides in the hours and the extras. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, helps owners find it, drawing on work with more than 1,000 small businesses.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Why Is My Busy Coffee Shop Not Making Money?

Because the morning rush pays for slow afternoons and free extras that nobody counted. Pull sales by the hour from your register and set them against who was on the clock. Selling hours where labor eats far more than your daily target are where the money goes. Then charge for the extras you give away, and cost your top drinks with the cup, lid and card fee included.

How This Guide WorksThis guide starts with Dr. Paul’s view, then your day hour by hour, a story where Louie Waffles, the Labrador who runs Waffle Woofs Bakery & Café, counts what “On the house!” really costs, three steps, what a drink really costs and the weekly numbers to watch. More stories like Louie’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

The Rush Is Not the Problem. The Rest of the Day Is.

Owners look at a packed morning and assume the business works. Dr. Paul looks at every hour separately. The rush usually pays well. The hours after it, staffed like the rush, and the extras handed out all day, are where profit leaks. Matching labor to each hour and pricing the extras is the work in Dr. Paul’s business profitability consulting.

Hour by Hour

Which Hours Lose Money in a Coffee Shop?

Labor is the cost that moves. Average hourly earnings of restaurant employees were up 41% from pre-pandemic levels, per the National Restaurant Association.

One weekday, sampleSalesBaristasLaborLabor share
6 to 7 a.m.$4202$4010%
7 to 8 a.m.$7803$608%
8 to 9 a.m.$6903$609%
11 a.m. to noon$2603$6023%
1 to 2 p.m.$1403$6043%
2 to 3 p.m.$1102$4036%

Example only, labor at $20 an hour with payroll costs. This shows six selling hours; add opening, closing and manager hours, and most shops land near 25% to 35% for the day. Ingredients, cups and rent still come out of every dollar, so the afternoon hours lose money.

Doctor Owl Teaches

What Did Louie Learn From “On the House”?

On the House

Doctor Owl was counting the free bookmarks the library gave away each week. It was more than he guessed, and each one cost a little ink.

Louie Waffles bounded in, flour on his ears. “Waffle Woofs is the busiest shop in the forest!” he said. “There is a line every morning. But my honey jar is nearly empty.”

“Who works in the afternoon?” Doctor Owl asked.

“Everyone! Same as the morning.”

“And how many customers come in the afternoon?”

Louie scratched behind his ear. “A few. The squirrels. The old tortoise.”

“And what do you say when someone wants extra honey on their bun?”

“On the house!” Louie wagged.

That week, Louie counted. Every hour, he wrote down the acorns in and the helpers working. Mornings were full of acorns. Afternoons, four helpers stood around waiting for the tortoise.

He counted the free extra honey too. Forty spoonfuls a day.

So in the afternoon he kept two helpers and sent the rest home after the rush. Extra honey now cost one small acorn. Most customers paid it without a word.

At the end of the moon, Louie’s honey jar was fuller than it had been all year. He still said “On the house!” sometimes. Just not forty times a day.

In the library, Doctor Owl ordered fewer bookmarks.

The lesson: a busy morning hides slow hours and small giveaways; count them hour by hour.

Louie Waffles and Waffle Woofs Bakery & Café are from the Fabled Forest. The full line and the empty account are real.

What to Do

How Do I Find Where My Coffee Shop Loses Money?

Finding the leak takes three stages from Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Export two weeks of sales by hour and the schedule for the same days. Work out labor as a share of sales for each hour.

2. Plan

Trim or shift staff in the hours far above your target. Cost your top ten drinks with cup, lid and card fee. List every free extra.

3. Grow

Charge for the extras, reprice drinks that fall short and check labor by hour every week.

Not open yet? Plan staffing by hour before you hire. The coffee shop business plan template has a staffing and sales plan to build from.

Shift lead? When the line clears, send one person to prep or home early, and log it. That one decision moves the month.

Drink Cost

What Do the Ingredients in a Latte Cost?

16 oz oat milk latte at $5.75, sampleCost
Double shot of espresso$0.45
Oat milk$1.05
Cup, lid and sleeve$0.32
Card fee at 3%$0.17
Ingredients, cup and card fee$1.99, about 35% of the price

Labor and rent come on top. Free extras add up too: a $0.70 oat milk swap given away 40 times a day is $28 a day in sales never rung up, about $10,000 a year if you open daily.

Weekly Numbers

Which Numbers Should a Coffee Shop Owner Check Every Week?

Labor share by hour. The slow hours are where staffing changes pay off.

Average ticket. Shows whether add-ons and food are selling.

Free and comped items. Ring them in at zero so you can see them.

Cost of the top ten drinks. Update when milk, cups or coffee prices change.

What Else Do Coffee Shop Owners Ask About Profit?

What should labor be as a share of sales?

Many shops land around 25% to 35% overall. Your own target comes from your rent and costs, so check it by hour, not just by month.

Should I close earlier?

Look at the last two hours first. If sales do not cover the staff, utilities and waste for those hours, shorter hours or one barista can make sense.

Will regulars mind paying for extras?

Most expect it. Post the prices, keep them small and stop giving away what you now charge for.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He builds the hour-by-hour view, the drink costs and a weekly check with you.

This is one of six guides for coffee shop and bakery owners. See them all on the Coffee Shops and Bakeries page.

Not sure which items make money? See the Sanford business consultant page.

Once you know which hours lose money, prices are next; see raising the right coffee shop prices in small steps.

What Share of Sales Did Labor Take at 2 p.m. Yesterday?

Bring two weeks of sales by hour to a free 15-minute call. Dr. Paul helps coffee shops find the leak in business profitability consulting. His rates are on the pricing page.

Find Your Profit Leak

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, has advised more than 1,000 small businesses in all 50 states and Canada. He holds a DBA from National University and an MBA in Finance from Webster University and wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Sources

Scroll to Top