Home › Who We Help › Roofing and Remodeling › Storm Chasers and Lowball Bids

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Compete With Storm Chasers and Lowball Roofing Bids?

Two days after the hail, out-of-state trucks are parked on every street. They knock on every door, promise a free roof and fast paperwork on insurance jobs, and underbid on retail jobs by cutting corners. Some homeowners sign on the spot. A few will call you in a year when the roof leaks and the other company is gone. Contractor fraud reports have climbed sharply in recent years, and homeowners know it. Local roofers who work with Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant, learn to turn that worry into their advantage: proof they are local and staying, a plain explanation of the claim and a bid that shows the whole roof.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Do I Win Roofing Jobs Without the Lowest Price?

Show proof that you are local and will be here: your years in town, local permits pulled, a manufacturer warranty registered in the homeowner’s name, and reviews from their neighborhood. Explain the claim in plain words before anyone signs: what the insurer pays, when, and what the homeowner owes. Price the whole roof system on the bid, line by line, so a homeowner can see what a lower bid leaves out. Never waive a deductible.

How This Guide WorksThis guide covers what the fraud numbers mean for honest roofers, a line-by-line bid comparison, the proof homeowners look for, three steps and a story where a badger roofer loses a street to a crew from out of town. More stories like the badger’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Fraud Numbers

How Common Is Storm Chaser Fraud?

Common enough that homeowners are wary. Reported contractor fraud rose 38% from 2023 to 2025, according to the National Insurance Crime Bureau, and 36 states now support its Contractor Fraud Awareness Week, as Carrier Management reported. The NICB tells homeowners to get multiple estimates, ask for references and verify an active local business license, per Scripps News.

Every one of those checks favors the local roofer. Make it easy for homeowners to run them on you.

A Comparison

What Does a Lowball Roofing Bid Leave Out?

LineYour bidTypical lowball bid
Full tear-off to the deckIncludedSometimes
Decking replaced, per sheetPricedNot mentioned
Ice and water shield, drip edgeIncludedOften missing
VentilationBalanced, includedNot mentioned
PermitPulled locallyOften skipped
WarrantyRegistered in the homeowner’s nameVerbal

What to Say

What Should a Local Roofer Say at the Door After a Storm?

Lead with the address: “We are on Main Street, and we have roofed in town for eighteen years.”

Point to proof: “Here are the permits we pulled on your street, and a neighbor’s review.”

Explain, do not promise: “Here is how your claim pays and what you owe. Your adjuster sets the scope.”

Show the whole roof: “Here is every line on the bid, so you can compare it.”

Never: offer to waive the deductible.

What to Do

How Do I Win Against Out-of-Town Crews?

Winning on trust takes three stages, which mirror Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Gather your proof: years in business, permits pulled in town, manufacturer certifications, reviews by neighborhood and photos of local roofs.

2. Plan

Write a one-page claim guide in plain words. Lay out your bid line by line: tear-off, decking, underlayment, ice and water, drip edge, ventilation, permit, warranty, cleanup.

3. Grow

After every storm, visit your past customers’ streets first, with the claim guide and the bid layout. Ask each happy customer for a review and a yard sign.

Not open yet? Plan your local proof from the first roof: permits, registered warranties, reviews. The roofing contractor business plan template has a marketing section for it.

Sales rep? Lead with the claim guide, not the price. Homeowners remember who explained it.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Your Address Is Your Best Sales Tool

Local roofers try to match the storm chaser’s price. Dr. Paul has them match the homeowner’s fear instead. After a storm, homeowners are not shopping for the cheapest roof. They are trying not to get burned. A roofer who shows a local office, a registered warranty and a plain explanation of the claim is the safe choice, at a fair price. Building that message and the bid layout with you is the work in Dr. Paul’s marketing strategy consulting.

Doctor Owl Teaches

How Did the Badger Lose a Street to a Crew From Out of Town?

Trucks on Every Corner

Doctor Owl was turning away a traveling knife sharpener, who had knocked on every door in the lane, when the badger roofer came up the path looking glum.

“Hail on Tuesday,” the badger said. “By Thursday, trucks from three forests away were on every corner. They signed half of Maple Lane. Cheaper than I can roof it.”

“Will they be here next spring?” asked Doctor Owl.

“Never are.”

“Do the families on Maple Lane know that?”

The badger thought about it. He had roofed in the forest for eighteen years. He had pulled permits for most of the lane. Not one homeowner had heard that from him.

That week he made two pages. One explained the claim in plain words: who pays what, when, and what the family owes. The other laid out his bid line by line: tear-off, decking, underlayment, drip edge, vents, permit, a warranty in the family’s name, cleanup.

He took both pages to Elm Lane, where he had roofed six houses the year before, and knocked on the other doors with a neighbor who loved her roof.

He did not win every house. He won most. One family showed him the cheaper bid, and together they looked for the drip edge, the vents and the permit. None were on it.

The knife sharpener moved on to the next forest. Doctor Owl kept his knives with the cobbler down the road, who had been there for thirty years.

The lesson: after a storm, homeowners buy safety before price, so show them you are local, plain and staying.

The badger is a Fabled Forest roofer. Out-of-town trucks on every corner after hail are not made up.

What Else Do Roofers Ask About Storm Chasers?

I’m starting a roofing company. How do I build trust with no history?

Get licensed and insured, pull permits on every job, register manufacturer warranties and collect a review from every customer from the first roof.

How does Dr. Paul help?

He builds your proof list, claim guide and bid layout with you, and plans the post-storm outreach to your best streets.

Should I lower my price to compete?

On insurance jobs, the adjuster’s scope sets the price, so compete on speed, proof and paperwork. On retail jobs, show the homeowner what the lower bid leaves out. A line-by-line bid does the arguing for you.

Can I negotiate the claim for the homeowner?

In many states, no; that is a licensed public adjuster’s job. You can explain the claim, document the damage and send supplements for the work. The homeowner deals with the adjuster.

Is waiving the deductible a way to compete?

No. In many states it is insurance fraud. It also tells honest homeowners you will cut corners somewhere else.

How do I get reviews from the right neighborhoods?

Ask every happy customer at the final walk-through, and ask for a yard sign. Reviews from their street matter more to a homeowner than stars from across the county.

All six guides for roofing and remodeling owners are listed on the Roofing and Remodeling page.

A Michigan owner stopped chasing price shoppers: see the Grand Rapids business consultant page.

Beating a lowball bid is easier when the scope is written down. Learn pricing remodel change orders so they pay.

Tree services face storm chasers too. Here is how to bid tree removal jobs that still make money.

Tired of Losing Streets to Out-of-Town Trucks?

You have something no storm chaser has: an address in town and years of roofs to prove it. Dr. Paul builds that into your sales message with roofers in marketing strategy consulting. Bring your last lost bid to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Bring Your Last Lost Bid to a Free Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Competing without being the cheapest is a regular part of the work for Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, who has helped more than 1,000 small businesses across all 50 states and Canada. He holds an MBA in Finance from Webster University and a DBA from National University, and he wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Sources

Scroll to Top