Home › Who We Help › Auto Repair Shops › Most Profitable Jobs

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

Which Auto Repair Jobs Make the Most Profit?

Which work paid you more last month: a month of tire jobs or a month of diagnostics? Most owners answer by feel, and feel favors the jobs that keep the bays busy. Busy and profitable are different things. A job that ties up a lift for two hours with a big parts bill can earn less than a one-hour diagnosis. One number settles it, and it is the one Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, a business consultant, walks owners through first: gross profit per hour of bay time, by type of job.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

Which Repair Jobs Make My Shop the Most Money?

The ones with the highest gross profit per hour of bay time. For each job type, take labor and parts sales, subtract the cost of the parts and the tech pay for that job, then divide by the hours the bay was tied up. In most shops, labor-heavy work like diagnostics and brakes beats parts-heavy work and quick, low-price jobs. Your own repair orders will tell you for sure.

How This Guide WorksYou will see what the benchmarks say about labor and parts profit, a worked example, how to pull your own numbers in an afternoon, three steps and a story where Ruben the Rhino almost buys the wrong machine. More stories like Ruben’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

The Benchmarks

Do Labor or Parts Make an Auto Shop More Profit?

Labor, as a share of each sale. Identifix puts labor profit margins at about 50% to 65% and parts margins at roughly 20% to just under 30%, according to its profit margin guide. MOTOR suggests a target of 70% or more for labor gross profit, about 60% overall and at least 100 dollars of gross profit per labor hour, in its guide to shop profits.

50 to 65%typical labor profit margin
20 to 30%typical parts profit margin
100+MOTOR target: dollars of gross profit per billed labor hour

That is why a parts-heavy job can look big on the invoice and small in the bank. For more on what to charge per hour, see the labor rate trend.

An Example

What Does Gross Profit per Bay Hour Look Like?

Job typeSalesParts and tech payBay hoursGross profit per bay hour
Diagnostics3,60090024about 113
Brakes9,8004,60052100
Maintenance7,2003,90048about 69
Tires12,5009,70060about 47

Illustration only, in dollars per month. Use your own repair orders. Bay hours run longer than billed labor hours, so these figures sit below a per labor hour target.

In this example, tires bring the most sales and the least profit per hour. Diagnostics bring the least sales and the most.

What to Do

How Do I Find My Most Profitable Jobs?

Finding your best jobs takes three stages, which mirror Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

Pull three months of repair orders. Group them into five to eight job types, such as diagnostics, brakes, tires, maintenance and electrical.

2. Plan

For each type, add up labor sales, parts sales, parts cost, tech pay and bay hours. Work out gross profit per bay hour. Rank the list.

3. Grow

Use the ranking. Book more of the top jobs, review the price on the bottom jobs and check your parts matrix. Rerun the numbers every quarter.

Building next year’s budget? Start from your job-type ranking, not last year’s sales total. The auto mechanic business plan template has a financial section for it.

Shop manager or service writer? You can pull the repair orders and build the first table. Hand the owner the ranking, not just the totals.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Sales Are Not Profit

Owners look at sales by job type and think they know what pays. Dr. Paul asks for one more column: hours of bay time. That one column changes the ranking in almost every shop he sees. A big parts sale looks great on the invoice and thin on the bank statement. Running that analysis with you, then pricing and scheduling from it, is the work in Dr. Paul’s profitability consulting.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Did Ruben Not Buy a Second Tire Machine?

The Machine on the Wish List

Ruben the Rhino found Doctor Owl in the garden, tallying which of his rows gave the most beans per hour of weeding. Ruben was holding a brochure.

“Second tire machine,” Ruben said. “Tires are my busiest job. More machines, more tires, more money.”

“Busiest,” said Doctor Owl. “Or best?”

Ruben frowned. “Is there a difference?”

Imani the Impala, his service writer, pulled three months of repair orders that night. She sorted them into piles: tires, brakes, maintenance, diagnostics, electrical. Beside each pile she wrote the hours the bays were tied up.

Tires were the biggest pile by far. But after the cost of the tires and the time on the lift, each bay hour on tires earned the least of any job. Diagnostics and brakes earned the most per hour, and there were cars waiting for both.

“So the busy job is the cheap job,” said Ruben.

“The busy job is the one that fills the hours,” said Imani. “The good jobs are waiting for those hours.”

Ruben put the brochure in a drawer. He raised his tire mount price, kept one bay open each morning for diagnostics and asked Imani to rerun the numbers every three months.

Doctor Owl went back to his beans. The row that took the longest to weed was coming out.

The lesson: rank jobs by profit per hour of bay time, not by how often they come in.

Ruben and Imani are fictional. The busiest job that pays the least is a real pattern.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Profitable Auto Repair Jobs?

What is gross profit per hour?

Sales from a job, minus the cost of its parts and the tech pay, divided by the hours the bay was in use. It tells you what an hour of your shop earns on that kind of work.

Should I stop doing low-profit jobs?

Not always. Some bring in new customers or lead to bigger work later. Price them fairly, and do not let them crowd out the jobs that pay best.

How should I price parts?

Use a parts matrix that sets markup by part cost, and review it when supplier prices change. Small, cheap parts can carry more markup than large, expensive ones.

I’m opening a shop. Which jobs should I focus on?

Look at what your area needs, what your techs do best and which jobs earn the most per hour. Plan your equipment around the work you want, not the work that walks in.

See five more guides for auto repair owners on the Auto Repair Shops page.

A Michigan owner learned the same lesson about job costs: see the Detroit, Michigan business consultant page.

Know your best jobs? Then get your service advisors to recommend them.

Want to Know Which Jobs Pay?

The bays tell you what is busy. The numbers tell you what pays. Dr. Paul reads them with owners in profitability consulting. Bring three months of repair orders to a free 15-minute call. Rates are on the pricing page.

Bring Your Repair Orders to a Free Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, asks auto shop owners for their bay hours before anything else. A business consultant with an MBA in Finance from Webster University and a DBA from National University, he has advised more than 1,000 small businesses across the U.S. and Canada and writes Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top