Home › Who We Help › Daycares › Keeping Teachers

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Keep Daycare Teachers When I Can’t Afford Raises?

Your best toddler teacher gives notice. The new job pays a dollar more an hour, at a big box store with no lesson plans. You cannot match it without raising tuition again. So you post the job, cover her room yourself and start over with someone new. What else can you offer that costs less than a raise but matters more to a teacher with young kids of her own? Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, who has advised more than 1,000 small businesses, finds the answer in a daycare is often already down the hall.

Call or text (321) 948-9588. Your first 15-minute call is free.

Last Updated: November 2026

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Can a Daycare Keep Teachers Without Big Raises?

Offer what a daycare has and a store does not: free or discounted care for teachers’ own children. Many teachers are young parents, and child care is often their biggest bill. Some states, like Kentucky, let child care staff qualify for subsidy, which can cover the cost. Then add paid planning time out of ratio each week and schedules posted two weeks ahead. Price these against a raise before you decide.

How This Guide WorksThis guide compares a raise with a benefits package, gives three steps, tells a story where the mother rabbit who runs the forest’s busiest nursery stops losing helpers to the mill, adds Dr. Paul’s view and ends with a quick score for your own program. More stories like the mother rabbit’s are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Two Paths

Is a Raise or a Benefit Worth More to a Teacher?

Teachers are close to the door. In NAEYC’s 2026 survey, 22% of early educators said they were considering leaving the field in the next year, and more than half of them said better wages and benefits, more support or loan forgiveness would make them stay, per NAEYC. Benefits count. When Kentucky made child care staff eligible for its subsidy, 3,600 children of child care workers were enrolled within a year, and centers said they could finally staff up, per NPR.

Sample center, 10 teachers, 3 with young childrenPath 1: $1 an hour raise for allPath 2: staff care plus planning time
What teachers getAbout $2,080 a year each, before taxesFree care for 3 children (worth $10,000 or more each) plus one paid planning hour a week for all 10
Yearly cost to youAbout $23,900 with payroll taxesAbout $10,000 for planning time, up to twice that if someone covers the room (less if taken at nap where your state allows), plus food and supplies for 3 children in open spots
Who it keepsEveryone a littleParents most; everyone gets planning time

Example only. If the staff child takes a spot you could have sold, count the lost tuition as the cost. Free care above the federal dependent care limit can count as taxable pay, so set the benefit up with your accountant first.

What to Do

How Do I Build a Package That Keeps Teachers?

Building a package teachers stay for follows three stages: Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy.

1. Organize

List every teacher with children under 12 and where those children go now. Look up whether your state lets child care staff qualify for subsidy. Count your open spots by room.

2. Plan

Price three options: free care, a staff discount and a small raise. Pick one, add one paid planning hour a week and write the rules: who qualifies, after how long and what happens if they leave.

3. Grow

Announce it at a staff meeting, start it on the first of a month and track who stays a year later.

Not open yet? Put a staff child care benefit in your budget from day one. It helps you hire your first teachers. The daycare business plan template has a staffing budget section to start from.

Lead teacher? Ask your director for one planning hour a week out of ratio. Show what you will plan with it. That hour is what keeps good teachers from burning out.

Doctor Owl Teaches

Why Were the Mother Rabbit’s Helpers Going to the Mill?

The Mill Paid More

Doctor Owl was oiling the hinges on the schoolhouse gate when the mother rabbit came by. She looked tired.

“Another helper left,” she said. “The mill pays a carrot more a day. I cannot.”

“Does the mill watch her little ones?”

She stopped. The helper had two kits of her own. Each morning she left them with her sister across the river, then walked an hour to the nursery.

“Who else has little ones?”

“Three of my helpers.”

“And do you have empty places?”

“Two in the hoppers’ room. They have been empty since spring.”

That week she changed the rule. Any helper who stayed a full season could bring her own kits, free, into an open place. She also gave each helper one quiet hour a week, out of the rooms, to plan games and stories.

The helper who had left came back before the first frost. The mill paid more, she said, but the mill did not have her kits down the hall.

By the next spring, no helper had left. The two empty places in the hoppers’ room were full of helpers’ kits, and the nursery’s waitlist had grown, because families liked seeing the same faces every morning.

Doctor Owl finished the gate. It swung without a sound.

The lesson: the best benefit is the one a daycare already has: a safe place for a teacher’s own children.

The mother rabbit and her helpers are from the Fabled Forest. The teacher leaving for a dollar more is from real life.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

A Dollar an Hour Is Not the Only Way to Pay

Owners think the only answer is a raise they cannot fund. Dr. Paul asks how many teachers have children under five, and what those parents pay for care somewhere else. A spot in your own building can be worth more to that teacher than a raise, and cost you less, especially in a room with an open spot. Writing the benefit, the planning time and the rules into your staff handbook is the work in Dr. Paul’s business organization consulting.

Score Yourself

How Does Your Daycare Score as a Place to Work?

Give yourself one point for each yes.

  • Teachers with young children can enroll them here, free or at a real discount.
  • Every teacher gets paid planning time out of ratio each week.
  • Schedules are posted at least two weeks ahead.
  • Breaks happen on time, every day.
  • Teachers know what it takes to move up to lead teacher.
  • Someone thanks a teacher by name, in front of others, every week.

Four or more: you are ahead of most programs. Two or fewer: start with the first two.

What Else Do Daycare Owners Ask About Keeping Teachers?

Is free child care for staff taxable?

It can be. Rules on employee benefits are specific, so talk with your accountant before you start. A state subsidy for staff, where it exists, works differently.

What if a teacher’s child needs a spot in a full room?

Write the rule ahead: staff children get the next open spot in that room, after current waitlist families or before them. Decide once and apply it the same way every time.

Does paid planning time really keep teachers?

Teachers who never leave ratio plan at home, unpaid. One protected hour a week tells them their work matters, and it costs less than a raise.

This is one of six guides for daycare owners. See them all on the Daycares page.

The same pay squeeze shows up in other fields. See the Springfield, Massachusetts business consultant page on perks instead of raises.

Ratios depend on qualified staff. Read how daycares hire teachers who meet credential rules.

What Would You Pay to Never Post That Job Again?

Bring your staff list and your open spots to a free 15-minute call, and Dr. Paul will help you price the options. He builds staff handbooks and benefit rules for daycare owners in business organization consulting. See the pricing page for rates.

Talk Through Your Options

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

A DBA from National University and an MBA in Finance from Webster University sit behind the advice from Dr. Paul Borosky. He has helped more than 1,000 small businesses in all 50 states and Canada and wrote Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series. Meet Dr. Paul or browse his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top