Home › Current Small Business Issues › Payment Fraud

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant
Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBABusiness Consultant

How Do I Protect My Business From Payment Fraud?

One phone call stops most payment fraud. The hard part is making sure the call happens every time, by whoever is at the desk that day. Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, a business consultant, writes the roles and procedures that make it routine. The technical side belongs to an IT security specialist. This guide covers the people side in three trades where one trusted person often handles all the money.

Stage 1 of 3: Organize

You protect your business from payment fraud with a few written rules that everyone follows every time. Writing those rules is Organize work, where Dr. Paul’s Organize-Plan-Grow™ Strategy begins before its Plan and Grow stages. Organize means deciding who can approve a payment and how changes get checked. A business consultant documents those steps with you, and an IT security specialist handles the technical protections.

A free 15-minute call is one text away: (321) 948-9588.

Doctor Owl in Plain English

How Do I Stop Someone From Tricking Us Into Paying Them?

Make one rule. Before anyone changes where a payment goes, they call the vendor at a phone number you already had. Not the number in the email. It takes two minutes and it stops the most common trick. Then decide who is allowed to approve payments, and write it down.

Who is Doctor Owl? He is the business advisor in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest books. The advice in this box is real.

The Full Answer

What Are the Steps to Protect Payments?

Six rules cover most of the risk.

  1. Call back before changing payment details. Use a phone number you already had on file.
  2. Split the duties. The person who enters a bill should not be the only one who approves the payment.
  3. Set approval limits. Decide who can approve up to what amount. Anything above it needs the owner.
  4. Slow down urgent requests. Pressure to pay right now is the most common sign of a scam. Urgent means check twice.
  5. Review the bank statement monthly. The owner should look at it personally. Ten minutes catches what a busy office misses.
  6. Bring in an IT specialist. Passwords, backups and email security are their job, not your bookkeeper’s.

What This Means for Your Business

Where Is Each Kind of Business Exposed to Payment Fraud?

In a small company, one trusted person often does everything. They open the mail, enter the bills and send the payments. Nobody checks, because nobody ever had to. Fraud aims at that trust, and the money rarely comes back. The weak point sits in a different place in each trade.

In home care

The exposure is payroll. Pay runs on caregiver timesheets, and a padded or made-up shift is easy to miss when the scheduler also approves the hours. The guide on keeping up with records and inspections uses the same cure: a check done by someone other than the record keeper.

In trucking

The exposure is in the paperwork that moves money: settlements, fuel receipts and payment instructions from brokers and factoring companies. A changed bank detail in an email can redirect a whole load’s pay. See keeping up with trucking paperwork.

In a dental or medical office

The exposure is the front desk. The doctor is with patients, and one person handles collections, deposits and vendor bills with little oversight. Written authority matters here. The guide on managing office staff puts it on paper.

Different trades, same opening: one person, no second look and no written rule. A rule does not accuse anyone. It gives the person at the desk a reason to slow down and a script to follow.

What to Measure

How Does Each Business Check That Its Payments Are Safe?

Track one number everywhere: the share of payment changes that were confirmed by a second step before any money moved. The target is all of them. If you got five requests to change payment details last year and called to confirm three, your number is 60%. There is no trade average worth chasing here. The benchmark is 100%, and each trade has its own place to check.

TradeBenchmark to watchHow to read it
Home careTimesheets matched to visit records before each payrollSomeone other than the scheduler does the match. Count the shifts that could not be matched. The goal is zero.
TruckingLoads with a signed bill of lading and a same-day invoiceCheck settlements against your own records in one set hour each week. Any payment instruction that changed gets a phone call first.
Dental and medicalDeposits matched to the day’s collectionsSomeone other than the person who took the payments does the match. The owner reads the bank statement every month.

None of these needs software. Each one is a second set of eyes on a step that one person used to do alone. That is the whole idea, and it costs a few minutes a week.

Technical safeguards such as passwords, backups and email security are a separate job for an IT security specialist. If your trade is not listed, start with the callback rule and add one second-person check on your largest regular payment.

How a Business Consultant Can Help

How Does Business Organization and SOPs Consulting Keep Payments Safe?

Fraud prevention on the people side is a matter of roles and written steps, which is Dr. Paul’s business organization and SOPs service. It sets clear roles, responsibilities and decision rights, and writes step-by-step procedures for the work that repeats.

It begins by listing the recurring tasks, who does each one today and where things go wrong. Much of that knowledge lives in one person’s head. Then the steps are written down with the people who do the work, along with who decides what. The procedures are kept short and stored in one place. After that, they are used for training, checked and updated.

Here is how that looks in each trade.

  • Home care: the payroll procedure names who schedules, who verifies visits and who approves pay, and those are not the same person.
  • Trucking: the paperwork procedure sets a rhythm per load and per week, and it requires a callback before any change to where a payment goes.
  • Dental and medical: the office manager gets written authority with limits, and a second person matches deposits to collections.

An IT security specialist then assesses and installs the technical protections. Dr. Paul’s part is done on site or over Zoom.

A practical deliverable

Defined roles and decision rights for payments, short written procedures and one place where they are kept.

Current signal: the rank for payment fraud this month is on the top 10 small business problems countdown.

Start Here

Where Do I Start This Week?

Tell your team today: no payment detail gets changed from an email alone. Call a number you already have on file first.

Not open yet? Set your payment rules before you hire your first office person. Add them to the operations notes in your business plan template.

Manager, not the owner? If you pay the bills, you are the last line of defense. You can start the callback rule yourself tomorrow.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant

Dr. Paul’s Take

Trust Your People. Check the Request

Some owners resist payment rules because they trust their staff. The rule is not about the staff. It protects them. A bookkeeper who must call back before changing an account can never be blamed for falling for a fake email.

What Should I Read Next?

Related issue: getting started with AI. See all ten issues on the current small business issues countdown.

Trade details come from Dr. Paul’s industry guides, linked above. Featured trades change monthly.

Next section is fiction. Welcome to the Fabled Forest.

How Do Fabled Forest Security Experts Nearly Get Fooled?

A Fabled Forest Story: The Crandall Twins and the Urgent Letter

Doctor Owl was fitting a new padlock on the garden shed when a gull dropped a letter at his feet by mistake. It was addressed to Hard to Shell.

He walked it down to the coast. Sheldon and Percy Crandall were mid-argument, as usual.

The letter claimed to be from their lock supplier. New owners, it said. Send this month’s acorn-coins to a different burrow. Urgent.

“Bolt it down,” said Sheldon. “We pay on time. Send it.”

“Back it up,” said Percy. “Copy the letter first. Then send it.”

“Before either,” said Doctor Owl, “who has spoken to the supplier?”

The twins looked at each other. Neither had.

Percy scuttled to the supplier’s shop, the one they had used for years. Same owner. No new burrow. No letter.

For once the twins agreed. They wrote a rule on the wall: no payment moves to a new place until one of them has heard it from the supplier in person.

Then they argued about whose handwriting was neater.

The lesson: check the request with the real source before any money moves.

More stories like the Crandall twins’ are in Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series.

Illustration only. The Crandall twins are invented. Fake change-of-payment requests are real.

What Else Do Owners Ask About Payment Fraud?

What is the most common fraud against small businesses?

A message that pretends to be a vendor or the owner and asks to change where a payment goes. A callback rule stops most of these.

Do I need cyber insurance?

Ask your insurance agent what your current policy covers. Many general policies leave out fraud losses.

I am just starting out. What should I set up first?

Separate business bank accounts, a rule for approving payments and strong passwords. An IT specialist can help with the last one.

You Built It by Hand. Is One Email All It Takes to Hurt It?

You spent years learning your trade and building trust with your team. Payment rules were never part of that training. Dr. Paul helps owners put simple controls on paper so a fake request has nowhere to land. Start the callback rule today. For the rest of the procedure, see his consulting services and the pricing page.

Claim a Free 15-Minute Call

Or call or text (321) 948-9588.

Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, Business Consultant and author

About the Author

The author of Dr. Paul’s Fabled Forest Business School Series, Dr. Paul Borosky, DBA, MBA, is a working business consultant. He holds a DBA from National University and an MBA in Finance from Webster University. He has helped 1,000+ small business owners across the United States and Canada. His procedure work keeps payments boring and safe. Meet Dr. Paul or find his books on Amazon.

Scroll to Top